State of Arizona Office of Administrative Hearings

Electronic Case File

21-004-WQAB/21-006-WQAB
In the Matter of: Chris Werhoven AND Patgonia Area Resource Alliance, Defenders of Wildlife, Arizona Mining Reform Coalition, Borderlands Restoration Network, Center for Biological Diversity, Earthworks, Firends of the Santa Cruz River, Friends of Sonoita Creek, Sky Island Alliance, and Tucson Audubon Society -VS- State of Arizona Department of Environmental Quality and Arizona Minerals Inc.


Document Number Filing Date Document Type Description Filed By
110/26/2021 - originally filed on 10/8/21 posted this date by webmasterRequest for HearingRequest for HearingWebmaster on behalf of Self - Webmaster
210/26/2021 - originally filed on 10/19/21 posted this date by webmasterMisc. Motion (specified in description)Motion for Status ConferenceWebmaster on behalf of Self - Webmaster
310/26/2021 - originally filed on 10/20/21 posted this date by webmasterNotice of HearingNotice of HearingWebmaster on behalf of Self - Webmaster
410/26/2021Agency RecordAgency RecordConnie Castillo on behalf of Clerk of the Board - Agency
510/26/2021Agency RecordAgency RecordConnie Castillo on behalf of Clerk of the Board - Agency
610/26/2021Pre-Hearing OrderCASE MANAGEMENT ORDER No. 1Thomas Shedden on behalf of Self - Administrative Law Judge
710/26/2021Pre-Hearing OrderCASE MANAGEMENT ORDER No. 2 Thomas Sheddden on behalf of Self - Administrative Law Judge
810/27/2021Notice of AppearanceNotice of Appearance - filed Jothi BeljanWebmaster on behalf of Self - Webmaster
911/4/2021Order Setting Prehearing/Status ConferenceCASE MANAGEMENT ORDER No. 3Thomas Shedden on behalf of Self - Administrative Law Judge
1011/5/2021Notice of AppearanceNotice of AppearanceAndrea Driggs on behalf of Arizona Minerals Inc. - Intervenor
1111/5/2021Minute EntryMinute Entry No. 1Thomas Shedden on behalf of Self - Administrative Law Judge
1211/5/2021Misc. NoticeReview of Documents filed w WQABJothi Beljan on behalf of ADEQ - Agency
1311/12/2021Misc. Motion (specified in description)AMI Corporate DisclosureChris Thomas on behalf of Arizona Minerals, Inc. - Intervenor
1411/12/2021Agency RecordADEQ Reply in Support of Motion to Dismiss-PARA v ADEQThomas Shedden on behalf of Self - Administrative Law Judge
1511/12/2021Agency RecordWerkhoven Response to ADEQ Motion - Werkhoven v ADEQThomas Shedden on behalf of Self - Administrative Law Judge
1611/15/2021Pre-Hearing MemorandumCorporate Disclosure & Statement of RepresentationBilly Peard on behalf of Patagonia Area Resource Alliance - Appellant
1711/15/2021Misc. NoticeNotice of Voluntary Withdrawal Randy Serraglio on behalf of Center for Biological Diversity - Appellant
1811/16/2021Misc. Motion (specified in description)notice of voluntary withdrawalAaron Mintzes on behalf of Earthworks - Appellant
1911/22/2021Pre-Hearing OrderCASE MANAGEMENT ORDER No. 4 Thomas Shedden on behalf of Self - Administrative Law Judge
2012/1/2021Pre-Hearing OrderCASE MANAGEMENT ORDER No. 5Thomas Shedden on behalf of Self - Administrative Law Judge
2112/1/2021Misc. Motion (specified in description)Tucson Audubon Society’s Notice of Voluntary WithdrawalThomas Shedden on behalf of Self - Administrative Law Judge
2212/7/2021Notice of AppearanceNotice of AppearanceTodd Gwillim on behalf of Arizona Minerals, Inc. - Intervenor
2312/9/2021Notice of AppearanceNotice of AppearanceAlisha Tarin-Herman on behalf of Arizona Minerals, Inc. - Intervenor
2412/13/2021Misc. NoticeDisclosure of Competencechris werkhoven on behalf of chris werkhoven - Appellant
2512/13/2021List of Witnesses and ExhibitsADEQ Initial DisclosuresKimberly Corbett on behalf of ADEQ - Respondent
2612/13/2021List of Witnesses and ExhibitsAMI Initial DisclosureAlisha Tarin-Herman on behalf of Arizona Minerals, Inc. - Intervenor
2712/14/2021List of Witnesses and ExhibitsInitial DisclosuresWilliam Peard on behalf of Patagonia Area Resource Alliance - Appellant
2812/27/2021List of Witnesses and ExhibitsSupplemental Disclosurechris werkhoven on behalf of chris werkhoven - Appellant
2912/27/2021List of Witnesses and ExhibitsSupplemental Disclosurechris werkhoven on behalf of chris werkhoven - Appellant
3012/27/2021List of Witnesses and ExhibitsSupplemental Disclosurechris werkhoven on behalf of chris werkhoven - Appellant
3112/27/2021List of Witnesses and ExhibitsSupplemental Disclosurechris werkhoven on behalf of chris werkhoven - Appellant
3212/27/2021List of Witnesses and ExhibitsAMI Supplemental DisclosureAlisha Tarin-Herman on behalf of Arizona Minerals, Inc. - Intervenor
3312/28/2021Misc. Motion (specified in description)Motion for Virtual TestimonyAlisha Tarin-Herman on behalf of Arizona Minerals, Inc. - Intervenor
3412/29/2021Misc. Motion (specified in description)Motion to Relocate HearingAlisha Tarin-Herman on behalf of Arizona Minerals, Inc. - Intervenor
351/3/2022Pre-Hearing OrderCASE MANAGEMENT ORDER No. 6Thomas Shedden on behalf of Self - Administrative Law Judge
361/5/2022Pre-Hearing MemorandumNote on Exhibitschris werkhoven on behalf of chris werkhoven - Appellant
371/5/2022Motion for telephonic appearancePARA's Motion for Virtual Testimony of WitnessesBilly Peard on behalf of Patagonia Area Resource Alliance - Appellant
37a1/7/2022Combined Hearing ExhibitsCombined Hearing ExhibitsWebmaster on behalf of self - Webmaster
381/9/2022Misc. Motion (specified in description)Exhibit CorrectionAlisha Tarin-Herman on behalf of Arizona Minerals, Inc. - Intervenor
391/9/2022ExhibitsExhibit 60-AZ Mining BADCT Manual (full)Alisha Tarin-Herman on behalf of Arizona Minerals, Inc. - Intervenor
401/11/2022Misc. NoticeSelen-IX SlidesAndrea Driggs on behalf of Arizona Minerals Inc. - Intervenor
411/15/2022Misc. NoticeNote on Exhibits Correctionchris werkhoven on behalf of chris werkhoven - Appellant
421/18/2022Misc. NoticeNotice of LodgingAndrea Driggs on behalf of Arizona Minerals Inc. - Intervenor
431/20/2022Misc. NoticeNotice of FilingAlisha Tarin-Herman on behalf of Arizona Minerals, Inc. - Intervenor
441/24/2022Notice of Correction of, or Addition to, Previously Submitted Document (specified in document description)Second Note on Exhibitschris werkhoven on behalf of chris werkhoven - Appellant
451/26/2022Post-Hearing OrderCASE MANAGEMENT ORDER No. 7Thomas Shedden on behalf of Self - Administrative Law Judge
462/4/2022Misc. NoticeNotice of WithdrawalBilly Peard on behalf of Patagonia Area Resource Alliance - Appellant
472/8/2022Misc. NoticeNotice of RepresentationCarolyn Shafer on behalf of Patagonia Area Resource Alliance - Appellant
47a2/25/2022TranscriptTranscript - Day 1Webmaster on behalf of Self - Webmaster
47b2/25/2022TranscriptTranscript - Day 2Webmaster on behalf of Self - Webmaster
47c2/25/2022TranscriptTranscript - Day 3Webmaster on behalf of Self - Webmaster
47d2/25/2022TranscriptTranscript - Day 4Webmaster on behalf of Self - Webmaster
47e2/25/2022TranscriptTranscript - Day 5Webmaster on behalf of Self - Webmaster
47f2/25/2022TranscriptTranscript - Day 6Webmaster on behalf of Self - Webmaster
47g2/25/2022TranscriptTranscript - Day 7Webmaster on behalf of Self - Webmaster
47h2/25/2022TranscriptTranscript - Day 8Webmaster on behalf of Self - Webmaster
47i2/25/2022TranscriptTranscript - Day 9Webmaster on behalf of Self - Webmaster
482/25/2022Post-Hearing OrderCASE MANAGEMENT ORDER No. 8Thomas Shedden on behalf of Self - Administrative Law Judge
493/21/2022Proposed Findings of Fact and Conclusions of LawClosing Statementchris werkhoven on behalf of chris werkhoven - Appellant
503/21/2022Proposed Findings of Fact and Conclusions of LawAMI's Statement of Undisputed Material FactsChris Thomas on behalf of Arizona Minerals Inc. - Intervenor
513/21/2022Post-Hearing MemorandumADEQ's Closing ArgumentJothi Beljan on behalf of ADEQ - Respondent
523/21/2022Post-Hearing MemorandumAM's Closing BriefChris Thomas on behalf of Arizona Minerals Inc. - Intervenor
533/21/2022Post-Hearing MemorandumPost-Hearing MemorandumCarolyn Shafer on behalf of Patagonia Area Resource Alliance - Appellant
543/21/2022Proposed Findings of Fact and Conclusions of LawProposed Findings of Fact and Conclusions of LawCarolyn Shafer on behalf of Patagonia Area Resource Alliance - Appellant
553/24/2022Misc. NoticeADEQ NOTICE OF ERRATAJothi Beljan on behalf of ADEQ - Respondent
563/24/2022Misc. NoticeADEQ Amended Notice of ErrataJothi Beljan on behalf of ADEQ - Respondent
575/12/2022Misc. OrderCASE MANAGEMENT ORDER No. 9Thomas Shedden on behalf of Self - Administrative Law Judge

Click here to file a document in this matter.
(Parties only - Password required)