Greg Hanchett, Acting Director

Office of Administrative Hearings

1400 West Washington, Suite 101

Phoenix, Arizona 85007

Telephone Number: 602-542-9826

E-mail: greg.hanchett@azoah.com

 

 

IN THE SUPERIOR COURT OF THE STATE OF ARIZONA

IN AND FOR THE COUNTY OF MARICOPA

                       

In the Matter of: 

 

Hellsgate  Fire District dba

Rim Country Fire and Medical Service

 

Applicant.

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

LC2017-000297-001 DT

 

CERTIFICATION OF RECORD ON REVIEW

RECORD OF ADMINISTRATIVE HEARING

 

OAH No. 2017A-EMS-0006-DHS

 

 

 

 

CERTIFICATION OF RECORD ON REVIEW   

            Pursuant to A.R.S.  § 12-904(B), and in conformance with Administrative Order No. 2014-014, the undersigned hereby:  (1) transmits by certified mail the complete Administrative Record on Review to the Clerk of the Superior Court on media and in electronic format specified by the Clerk; (2) advises that an electronic copy of the original case documents and index of the Administrative Record on Review has been transmitted by mail to the superior court judge assigned to the case; and advises that the Office of Administrative Hearings will maintain, according to Arizona Code of Judicial Administration section 1-507 the original case documents and index constituting the Administrative Record on Review on its website, to remain unchanged for the duration of the appeal process to facilitate access by the Superior Court,

 

 and in the case of further appeal, to facilitate access by the Arizona Court of Appeals and the Supreme Court of Arizona.

             

            Done this ___ day of __________________, 2017.

 

 

                                                                        _________________________________

                                                                        Felicia Del Sol

                                                                        Custodian of the Records

 

 

 

 

 

 

A F F I D A V I T

 

STATE OF ARIZONA         )

                                            )

COUNTY OF MARICOPA   )

 

          Greg Hanchett, being first duly sworn upon his oath deposes and says:

          He is the duly appointed Director of the Office of Administrative Hearings for the State of Arizona and that Felicia Del Sol is custodian of its records and as such is authorized to search the files of the agency and to execute the attached affidavit and/or certification.

            The attached document bears the true and genuine signature of the employee whose name appears thereon.

            WITNESS MY HAND AND SEAL OF THIS OFFICE this ______day of

____________, 2017.

 

 

                                                            ___________________________________

                                                            GREG HANCHETT

                                                            OFFICE OF ADMINISTRATIVE HEARINGS

 

 

 

Subscribed and Sworn to before me

this _____ day of _________, 2017.

 

 

___________________________________

NOTARY PUBLIC

 

 

My Commission Expires:_______________________

 

 

 

                                                                       

 

 

The INDEX of RECORD on REVIEW and the complete Administrative Record on Review in approved form were transmitted by certified mail on this _____ day of _________________, 2017 to:

 

Clerk of the Court Attn: LC Specialty Desk

Maricopa County Superior Court

201 W. Jefferson (CCB)

Phoenix, Arizona 85003-2205

 

 

A copy of the INDEX of RECORD on REVIEW and an electronic copy of the original case documents and index of the Administrative Record on Review were transmitted by First Class mail on this _____ day of ________, 2017 to:

 

Honorable Patricia Ann Starr

C/O Clerk of the Court

Maricopa County Superior Court

201 West Jefferson, Suite 4A

Phoenix, Arizona 85203

 

 

 

 

A copy of the INDEX of RECORD on REVIEW was e-mailed/mailed on this _____ day of _________________, 2017 to:

 

Dr. Cara Christ

Arizona Department of Health Services

1740 West Adams, Room 203

Phoenix, AZ 85007

 

Jeffrey Meyerson

The Meyerson Law Firm, PLC

2555 E. Camelback Rd., Suite 140

Phoenix, Arizona 85016

Ronna L. Fickbohm

Fletcher Struse Fickbohm and Wagner, PLC

6750 N. Oracle Rd.

Tucson, Arizona 85704

 

David Bathke, Fire Chief

Hellsgate Fire District dba

Rim Country Fire and Medical Service

80 S. Walters Ln.

Payson, Arizona 85541

 

Kevin D. Ray, Assistant Attorney General

Molly Bonsall, Assistant Attorney General

Office of the Attorney General

1275 W. Washington

Phoenix, Arizona 85007

 

 

By Felicia Del Sol      

 

 


 

 

 

 

 

INDEX of RECORD on REVIEW

 

 

Superior Court No. LC2017-000297-001 DT

 

1. Original Agency Action From Which Review is Sought: A.R.S. 12-904(B)(1)

 

Number

Document Number

Filing Date

Document Type

Description

Filed By

1.

1

8/02/2016- posted by webmaster on 8/10/16

Request for Hearing

Request for Hearing

Webmaster on behalf of Self - Webmaster

2.

2

8/09/2016- posted by webmaster on 8/10/16

Notice of Hearing

Notice of Hearing

Webmaster on behalf of Self - Webmaster

3.

25

10/7/2016

Notice of Hearing

Amended Notice of Hearing

Miriam Johnson on behalf of Hellsgate Fire District dba Rim Country - Agency

 

 

 

 

2. Motions, Memoranda or Other Documents Submitted by the Parties to the Appeal: A.R.S. § 12-904(B)(2)

 

Number

Document Number

Filing Date

Document Type

Description

Filed By

4.

5

8/12/2016- posted by webmaster

Notice of Appearance

Notice of Appearance

Ronna L. Fickbohm on behalf of Rural Metro - Intervenor

5.

6

8/12/2016- posted by webmaster

Motion to Intervene

Motion to Intervene

Ronna L. Fickbohm on behalf of Rural Metro - Intervenor

6.

7

8/12/2016- posted by webmaster

Motion for telephonic appearance

Motion for Telephonic Appearance

Ronna L. Fickbohm on behalf of Rural Metro - Intervenor

7.

8

8/17/2016

Notice of Appearance

Notice of Appearance

Kevin D. Ray on behalf of Arizona Department of Health Services - Agency

8.

9

8/17/2016

Response to Misc. Motion (specified in description)

ADHS/BEMSTS' Resp to Motion to Intervene by Rural/Metro

Kevin D. Ray on behalf of Arizona Department of Health Services - Agency

9.

10

8/19/2016- originally received on 8/18/16. Posted this date by webmaster.

Notice of Appearance

Notice of Appearance

Jeffrey Meyerson on behalf of Self - Applicant

10.

11

8/19/2016- originally received on 8/18/16. Posted this date by webmaster.

Misc. Motion (specified in description)

Signed Motion to Reschedule

Jeffrey Meyerson on behalf of Self - Applicant

11.

12

8/25/2016

Response to Misc. Motion (specified in description)

ADHS/BEMSTS' Resp to Motion to Reschedule Hearing

Kevin D. Ray on behalf of Arizona Department of Health Services - Agency

12.

14

8/26/2016

Response to Motion to Continue

Response to Motion to Reschedule Hearing

Ronna L. Fickbohm on behalf of Rural Metro - Intervenor

13.

15

9/2/2016

Misc. Motion (specified in description)

32971-Stipulation re hearing date and deadlines

Jeffrey Meyerson on behalf of Self - Applicant

14.

17

10/5/2016

List of Witnesses and Exhibits

ADHS/BEMSTS's Initial List of Witnesses and Exhibits

Kevin D. Ray on behalf of Arizona Department of Health Services - Agency

15.

18

10/5/2016

Notice of Pre-Submission of Exhibits (CD with index live links to documents)

ADHS/BEMSTS' Statement Regarding Submission of Exhibits

Kevin D. Ray on behalf of Arizona Department of Health Services - Agency

16.

19

10/5/2016

List of Witnesses and Exhibits

Initial List of Witnesses and Exhibits

Jeffrey Meyerson on behalf of Hellsgate Fire District - Applicant

17.

20

10/5/2016

List of Witnesses and Exhibits

Life Line's List of Witnesses and Exhibits

Ronna L. Fickbohm on behalf of Life Line Ambulance - Intervenor

18.

21

10/6/2016

Notice of Pre-Submission of Exhibits (CD with index live links to documents)

Notice of Filing of Electronic Copies of Exhibits

Ronna L. Fickbohm on behalf of Life Line Ambulance - Intervenor

19.

22

10/6/2016

Exhibits

NOTICE OF FILING OF ELECTRONIC COPIES OF INITIAL EXHIBITS

Jeffrey Meyerson on behalf of HELLSGATE FIRE DISTRICT dba Rim Country - Applicant

20.

23

10/6/2016

Exhibits

NOTICE OF FILING OF ELECTRONIC COPIES OF INITIAL EXHIBITS

Jeffrey Meyerson on behalf of HELLSGATE FIRE DISTRICT dba Rim Country - Applicant

21.

24

10/6/2016

Misc. Notice

NOTICE OF FILING OF ELECTRONIC COPIES OF INITIAL EXHIBITS

Jeffrey Meyerson on behalf of HELLSGATE FIRE DISTRICT dba Rim Country - Applicant

22.

26

10/17/2016

Request for Subpoenas

Life Line's Request for Issuance of Subpoena Duces Tecum

Ronna L. Fickbohm on behalf of Life Line Ambulance - Intervenor

23.

27

10/17/2016

Misc. Motion (specified in description)

Motion to Extend Deadline for Subpoena Requests

Jeffrey Meyerson on behalf of Hellsgate Fire District - Applicant

24.

28

10/18/2016

Response to Misc. Motion (specified in description)

Life Line's Opposition to Applicant's Motion to Extend

Ronna L. Fickbohm on behalf of Life Line Ambulance - Intervenor

25.

30

10/25/2016

Posting of Denied Subpoenas

Subpoena Denied filed by Ronna Fickbohn

Webmaster on behalf of Self - Webmaster

26.

31

11/14/2016

List of Witnesses and Exhibits

Applicant's Final List of Witnesses and Exhibits

Jeffrey Meyerson on behalf of HELLSGATE FIRE DISTRICT dba Rim Country - Applicant

27.

32

11/14/2016

List of Witnesses and Exhibits

Applicant's Final List of Witnesses and Exhibits

Jeffrey Meyerson on behalf of HELLSGATE FIRE DISTRICT dba Rim Country - Applicant

28.

33

11/14/2016

List of Witnesses and Exhibits

Applicant's Final List of Witnesses and Exhibits

Jeffrey Meyerson on behalf of HELLSGATE FIRE DISTRICT dba Rim Country - Applicant

29.

34

11/14/2016

List of Witnesses and Exhibits

ADHS/BEMSTS's Supplemental List of Witnesses and Exhibits

Kevin D. Ray on behalf of Arizona Department of Health Services - Agency

30.

35

11/14/2016

Notice of Pre-Submission of Exhibits (CD with index live links to documents)

ADHS/BEMSTS' Statement Regarding Submission of Exhibits

Kevin D. Ray on behalf of Arizona Department of Health Services - Agency

31.

36

11/14/2016

Exhibits

NOTICE OF FILING OF ELECTRONIC COPIES OF INITIAL EXHIBITS

Jeffrey Meyerson on behalf of HELLSGATE FIRE DISTRICT dba Rim Country - Applicant

32.

37

11/14/2016

List of Witnesses and Exhibits

First Amended and Supplemental List of Witnesses & Exhibits

Ronna L. Fickbohm on behalf of Life Line Ambulance - Intervenor

33.

38

11/15/2016

Notice of Pre-Submission of Exhibits (CD with index live links to documents)

Notice of Filing Electronic Copies of Exhibits

Ronna L. Fickbohm on behalf of Life Line Ambulance - Intervenor

34.

39

11/23/2016

Misc. Notice

Notice Withdrawing Intervention

Ronna L. Fickbohm on behalf of Rural/Metro Corporation (Maricopa) - Intervenor

35.

41

12/5/2016

List of Witnesses and Exhibits

APPLICANT’S REVISED FINAL LIST OF WITNESSES AND EXHIBITS

Jeffrey Meyerson on behalf of HELLSGATE FIRE DISTRICT dba Rim Country - Applicant

36.

42

12/5/2016

List of Witnesses and Exhibits

APPLICANT’S REVISED FINAL LIST OF WITNESSES AND EXHIBITS

Jeffrey Meyerson on behalf of HELLSGATE FIRE DISTRICT dba Rim Country - Applicant

37.

43

12/5/2016

List of Witnesses and Exhibits

APPLICANT’S REVISED FINAL LIST OF WITNESSES AND EXHIBITS

Jeffrey Meyerson on behalf of HELLSGATE FIRE DISTRICT dba Rim Country - Applicant

38.

44

12/5/2016

List of Witnesses and Exhibits

APPLICANT’S REVISED FINAL LIST OF WITNESSES AND EXHIBITS

Jeffrey Meyerson on behalf of HELLSGATE FIRE DISTRICT dba Rim Country - Applicant

39.

45

12/5/2016

Notice of Pre-Submission of Exhibits (CD with index live links to documents)

NOTICE OF FILING OF ELECTRONIC COPIES OF FINAL EXHIBITS

Jeffrey Meyerson on behalf of HELLSGATE FIRE DISTRICT dba Rim Country - Applicant

40.

46

12/5/2016

Notice of Pre-Submission of Exhibits (CD with index live links to documents)

NOTICE OF FILING OF ELECTRONIC COPIES OF FINAL EXHIBITS

Jeffrey Meyerson on behalf of HELLSGATE FIRE DISTRICT dba Rim Country - Applicant

41.

47

12/5/2016

Pre-Hearing Memorandum

Arizona Department of Health Services' Prehearing Memorandum

Kevin D. Ray on behalf of Arizona Department of Health Services - Agency

42.

48

12/5/2016

Pre-Hearing Memorandum

Intervenor Life Line's Prehearing Memorandum

Ronna L. Fickbohm on behalf of Life Line Ambulance - Intervenor

43.

49

12/5/2016

Pre-Hearing Memorandum

Pre-Hearing Memorandum

Jeffrey Meyerson on behalf of Hellsgate Fire District - Applicant

44.

50

12/15/2016

Notice of Pre-Submission of Exhibits (CD with index live links to documents)

ADHS/BEMSTS' Statement Regarding Submission of Exhibits

Kevin D. Ray on behalf of Arizona Department of Health Services - Agency

45.

52

2/14/2017

Proposed Findings of Fact and Conclusions of Law

ADHS Limited Proposed Findings of Fact & Conclusions of Law

Molly Bonsall on behalf of Arizona Department of Health Services - Agency

46.

53

2/14/2017

Post-Hearing Memorandum

Intervenor's Closing Argument

Ronna L. Fickbohm on behalf of Life Line Ambulance - Intervenor

47.

55

2/14/2017

Post-Hearing Memorandum

Life Line's Proposed Findings of Fact, Conclusions of Law...

Ronna L. Fickbohm on behalf of Life Line Ambulance - Intervenor

48.

56

2/14/2017

Proposed Findings of Fact and Conclusions of Law

FINDINGS OF FACT, CONCLUSIONS OF LAW AND RECOMMENDED ORDER

Jeffrey Meyerson on behalf of Hellsgate Fire District - Applicant

49.

57

2/15/2017

Notice of Correction of, or Addition to, Previously Submitted Document (specified in document description)

Life Line's Notice of Request to Webmaster

Ronna L. Fickbohm on behalf of Life Line Ambulance - Intervenor

50.

58

3/7/2017

Proposed Findings of Fact and Conclusions of Law

ADHS' Response to Applicants' Proposed Findings of Fact, Con

Molly Bonsall on behalf of Arizona Department of Health Services - Agency

51.

59

3/7/2017

Post-Hearing Memorandum

Life Line's Response to Applicant's Findings of Fact . . .

Ronna L. Fickbohm on behalf of Life Line Ambulance - Intervenor

52.

60

3/7/2017

Post-Hearing Memorandum

Response to Life Line Findings of Fact and Closing Argument

Jeffrey Meyerson on behalf of Hellsgate Fire District - Applicant

53.

61

3/15/2017

Misc. Notice

Inquiry Regarding Closure of Record/Request to Close Record

Jeffrey Meyerson on behalf of Hellsgate Fire District - Applicant

 

 

 

3. Administrative Law Judge Orders

 

 

Number

Document Number

Filing Date

Document Type

Description

Filed By

54.

3

8/10/2016

Pre-Hearing Order

CASE MANAGEMENT ORDER No. 1

Thomas Shedden on behalf of Self - Administrative Law Judge

55.

4

8/10/2016

Pre-Hearing Order

CASE MANAGEMENT ORDER No. 2

Thomas Shedden on behalf of Self - Administrative Law Judge

56.

13

8/26/2016

Pre-Hearing Order

CASE MANAGEMENT ORDER No. 3

Thomas Shedden on behalf of Self - Administrative Law Judge

57.

16

9/7/2016

Granting Motion to Continue

CASE MANAGEMENT ORDER No. 4

Thomas Shedden on behalf of Self - Administrative Law Judge

58.

29

10/19/2016

Pre-Hearing Order

CASE MANAGEMENT ORDER No. 5

Thomas Shedden on behalf of Self - Administrative Law Judge

59.

40

11/30/2016

Pre-Hearing Order

CASE MANAGEMENT ORDER No. 6

Thomas Shedden on behalf of Self - Administrative Law Judge

60.

51

12/22/2016

Misc. Order

CASE MANAGEMENT ORDER 7

Thomas Shedden on behalf of Self - Administrative Law Judge

61.

62

3/20/2017

Minute Entry

Minute Entry No. 1

Thomas Shedden on behalf of Self - Administrative Law Judge

62.

63

4/10/2017

Order Closing Record

CASE MANAGEMENT ORDER No. 8

Thomas Shedden on behalf of Self - Administrative Law Judge

 

 

4. Exhibits Admitted as Evidence at the Administrative Hearing: A.R.S. § 12-904(B)(3); Exhibits Offered, but not Admitted or Withdrawn

 

Number

Exhibit Number

Description

Admitted

Not Admitted

Not Offered

Withdrawn

63.

ADHS-1

Initial C.O.N. Application

 12/12/16

 

 

 

64.

ADHS-2

Administratively Incomplete Letter

 12/12/16

 

 

 

65.

ADHS-3

Response to Administratively Incomplete Letter

 12/12/16

 

 

 

66.

ADHS-4

Request to Amend Response Times

 12/12/16

 

 

 

67.

ADHS-5

Administratively Complete Letter

 12/12/16

 

 

 

68.

ADHS-6

Notice of Substantive Review

 12/12/16

 

 

 

69.

ADHS-7

Substantive Review Response

 12/12/16

 

 

 

70.

ADHS-8

Substantive Review Response to Question #20

 

 

 

 

71.

ADHS-9

Findings Letter

 12/12/16

 

 

 

72.

ADHS-10

Response to Finding Letter

 12/12/16

 

 

 

73.

ADHS-11

CON Guidance Document

 12/12/16

 

 

 

74.

ADHS-12

Email to Neighboring CON Holders

 12/12/16

 

 

 

75.

ADHS-13

AMR's Objection to Application

 12/12/16

 

 

 

76.

ADHS-14

Email re Amended Service Area Description

 12/12/16

 

 

 

77.

ADHS-15

Map of Final Proposed Service Area

 12/12/16

 

 

 

78.

ADHS-16

Final Hellsgate Map with Overlaps

 12/12/16

 

 

 

79.

ADHS-17

Amended Notice of Hearing

 12/12/16

 

 

 

80.

ADHS-18

Substantive Review Response to Question #20

 12/14/16

 

 

 

81.

HGFD-1

RIM_COUNTRY_ARCR_PROFORMA_

 12/12/16

 

 

 

82.

HGFD-2

Hellsgate CON application

 

 

 X

 

83.

HGFD-3

CSA arcr 2009-2012

 12/14/16

 

 

 

84.

HGFD-4

Canyon-State-Ambulance-ARCR-2013

 12/14/16

 

 

 

85.

HGFD-5

canyon-state-ambulance-arcr-2014

 12/14/16

 

 

 

86.

HGFD-6

Overall response time tolerances

 12/12/16

 

 

 

87.

HGFD-7

Response time tolerances Station 11

 12/12/16

 

 

 

88.

HGFD-8

Response time tolerances Station 21

 12/12/16

 

 

 

89.

HGFD-9

Response time tolerances Station 22

 12/12/16

 

 

 

90.

HGFD-10

Response time tolerances Station 31

 12/12/16

 

 

 

91.

HGFD-11

Proposed form Ambulance Back-Up Agreement

 12/12/16

 

 

 

92.

HGFD-12

Proposed form Ambulance Back-Up Agreement

 12/12/16

 

 

 

93.

HGFD-13

Proposed form Ambulance Back-Up Agreement

 12/12/16

 

 

 

94.

HGFD-14

Proposed form Ambulance Back-Up Agreement

 12/12/16

 

 

 

95.

HGFD-15

2015 Phx Group Transports [HGFD 15 – a]

 12/12/16

 

 

 

96.

HGFD-15

2016 PHX GRP RECAP [HGFD 15- b]

 12/12/16

 

 

 

97.

HGFD-16

PSFD Ambulance Mutual Aid into CON 58

 12/13/16

 

 

 

98.

HGFD-17

2015 R111 Response Report [HGFD 17 – a]

 12/13/16

 

 

 

99.

HGFD-17

2016 R111 response report [HGFD 17 – b]

 12/13/16

 

 

 

100.

HGFD-18

2016 HELLSGATE EMS call data

 12/12/16

 

 

 

101.

HGFD-19

Hellsgate Proposed Boundaries

 12/12/16

 

 

 

102.

HGFD-20a

CanyonStateCertificate 58

 

 

 X

 

103.

HGFD-20b

CON No. 81 (Pine-Strawberry FD)

 

 

 X

 

104.

HGFD-20c

CON No. 112 (Tonto Basin FD)

 

 

 X

 

105.

HGFD-20d

CON No. 126 (Tri-City FD)

 

 

 X

 

106.

HGFD-20e

CON No. 128 (Blue Ridge Fire District)

 

 

 X

 

107.

HGFD-20f

CON No. 104 (Action Medical Services, Inc. - Winslow)

 

 

 X

 

108.

HGFD-20g

Renewal Application

 12/13/16

 

 

 

109.

HGFD-21a

HGFD annual reported financials FYE 06-30-2014

 12/12/16

 

 

 

110.

HGFD-21b

HGFD annual reported financials FYE 06-30-2015

12/12/16 

 

 

 

111.

HGFD-21c

HFD Financial Reports Recap June 2016

 12/12/16

 

 

 

112.

HGFD-22a

HGFD Annual Budget - FYE 06-30-2014

 12/12/16

 

 

 

113.

HGFD-22b

HGFD Annual Budget - FYE 06-30-2015

 12/12/16

 

 

 

114.

HGFD-22c

HFD Financial Reports Recap June 2016

 12/12/16

 

 

 

115.

HGFD-23

HFD Financial Reports Recap June 2016

 

 

 X

 

116.

HGFD-24a

Lifeline 2015 ARCR

 12/12/16

 

 

 

117.

HGFD-24b

AZDHS Financial Performance Findings June 22 - 2016

 12/12/16

 

 

 

118.

HGFD-25

RIM COUNTRY FIRE AND MEDICAL SERVICE IGA

 12/12/16

 

 

 

119.

HGFD-26

Rim Country Fire Med LOI

 12/12/16

 

 

 

120.

HGFD-27a

Bathke Resume

 12/12/16

 

 

 

121.

HGFD-27b

DavidStaubResume 2016 (2)

 12/13/16

 

 

 

122.

HGFD-27c

Bio Gary Morris Full

 12/13/16

 

 

 

123.

HGFD-27d

Dean Taylor CV 2016

 12/14/16

 

 

 

124.

HGFD-27e

resume of Ralph Vassallo Jr

 

 

 X

 

125.

HGFD-27f

R Beery Statement of Qualifications

 

 

 X

 

126.

LLA-1a

CON No. 58 (R-M AZ Hold, Inc.dbaCanyStateAmbdbaPaysMediTranspdbaLifestarEMSdbaLifeLineAmb)

 12/13/16

 

 

 

127.

LLA-1b

CON No. 109 (RM Corp (Maricopa) dba RM Ambu Svc dba AZ MediTransp dba AMT)

 12/13/16

 

 

 

128.

LLA-1c

CON No. 46 (American ComTrans)

 12/13/16

 

 

 

129.

LLA-1d

CON No. 86 (SW General)

 12/13/16

 

 

 

130.

LLA-1e

CON No. 136 (American Medical Response (Maricopa)

 12/13/16

 

 

 

131.

LLA-1f

CON No. 81 (Pine-Strawberry FD)

 12/13/16

 

 

 

132.

LLA-1g

CON No. 112 (Tonto Basin FD)

 12/13/16

 

 

 

133.

LLA-1h

CON No. 126 (Tri-City FD)

 12/13/16

 

 

 

134.

LLA-1i

CON No. 128 (Blue Ridge Fire District)

 12/13/16

 

 

 

135.

LLA-1j

CON No. 104 (Action Medical Services, Inc. - Winslow)

 12/13/16

 

 

 

136.

LLA-1k

CON No. 139 (ABC Ambulance, LLC)

 12/13/16

 

 

 

137.

LLA-2a

Life Line Service Area

 12/13/16

 

 

 

138.

LLA-2b

cons-central

 12/13/16

 

 

 

139.

LLA-2c

cons-northern

 12/13/16

 

 

 

140.

LLA-2d

DHS Map Showing All CON Holders in the Area

 12/13/16

 

 

 

141.

LLA-3 aa

Chest Pain - Pain Decrease Chart

 12/15/16

 

 

 

142.

LLA-3 bb

2015 CPR World Challenge Smmary

 

 

 X

 

143.

LLA-3 cc

AMR World CPR Chal Sum (2016 results)

 12/15/16

 

 

 

144.

LLA-3dd

2016 PrehosEmergCare Arti (Nishikima et al) Medics and Antico-Antipl Use

 12/15/16

 

 

 

145.

LLA-3 ee

AMR Infographics (2016)

 12/15/16

 

 

 

146.

LLA-3ff

CDC-SOP for patient handoffs (ground ambulance)

 12/15/16

 

 

 

147.

LLA-3 gg

CDC-SOP for patient handoffs (air to ground ambulance)1

 12/15/16

 

 

 

148.

LLA-3a

Collab res with UofA - Prevalence of Hypervent

 12/15/16

 

 

 

149.

LLA-3b

Collab res with UofA - The Assoc Between EMS Resp Interval . . .

 

 

 X

 

150.

LLA-3c

Collab res with UofA - Charac of Medic-Assisted Intobat . . .

 

 

 X

 

151.

LLA-3d

Collab res with UofA - The Relati Betw Rapid Acute Physio Score . . and ALS Interv (02-24-26, 2011)

 

 

 X

 

152.

LLA-3e

Collab res with UofA - Poster on Ambul Crew Config ...(Cardiac Arrest)

 

 

 X

 

153.

LLA-3f

Collab res with UofA - Clini and Demog Attrib .. (PreHospital Intraoss Infus)

 

 

 X

 

154.

LLA-3g

Collab res with UofA - Poster on Relatio Between (RAPS) & Prehosp PatieAcuity, NAEMSP 2010

 

 

 X

 

155.

LLA-3h

Collab res with UofA - Poster on The Relatio Between Ambul Crew Config

 

 

 X

 

156.

LLA-3i

Collab res with UofA - Poster on The Relatio Between EMS Respo Interval . . . (RAPS) ..., 2011

 

 

 X

 

157.

LLA-3j

2013 Poster, Mobile Integrated Healthcare Practice

 12/15/16

 

 

 

158.

LLA-3k

12-2012 Consen manuscpt,, publi 2013 - Mobile Integ Hlthcare Practice - A Hlthcare Deli Strat

 12/15/16

 

 

 

159.

LLA-3l

JEMS article - As the Commu Paramed Concept Evolves, EMS Will Play an Integ Part (2013)

 12/15/16

 

 

 

160.

LLA-3m

Research paper (2014) Glasgow Coma Scale Scoring is Often Insacc

 

 

 X

 

161.

LLA-3n

Report - An Evidence-Based Prehos Guidline for Exter Hemor Control . . . (2014)

 12/15/16

 

 

 

162.

LLA-3o

Heart Rescue Proj (HRP), Commu Resps Plan Guide for Sudd Cardi Arrest (2011)

 

 

 X

 

163.

LLA-3p

Guide - Principles of Estab a Mobile Integr Hthcare Pract (MIHP)(2014)

 12/15/16

 

 

 

164.

LLA-3q

Early Detec & Treatm_Of_Patients_With_Severe_Sepsis_By_Prehosp_Person 2013

 

 

 X

 

165.

LLA-3r

PIM & PIT description

 12/15/16

 

 

 

166.

LLA-3s

EMS-CAHPS Pilot Survey Exec Summary - May 2014

 

 

 X

 

167.

LLA-3t

2014 CPR World Challenge Results

 

 

 

 

168.

LLA-3u

What Really Matters - Bourn article

 12/15/16

 

 

 

169.

LLA-3v

Silver Stevie award 06.17.14

 

 

 X

 

170.

LLA-3w

2013 SCA Facts AMR (2012 Data)

 12/15/16

 

 

 

171.

LLA-3x

2014 SCA Facts AMR (2013 Data)

 12/15/16

 

 

 

172.

LLA-3y

2015 SCA Facts AMR (2014 Data)

 12/15/16

 

 

 

173.

LLA-3z

2016 SCA Facts AMR (2015 Data)

 12/15/16

 

 

 

174.

LLA-4

American Medical Response Inc 03-31-16 thru 03-17-2014 Casualty Program Chart (Insurance)

 

 

 X

 

175.

LLA-5a

WP Rocket Holdings-Stipulated Proposed FOF&COL

 12/16/16

 

 

 

176.

LLA-5b

WP Rocket Holdings-ALJ Decision dated Jan 8, 2016

 12/16/16

 

 

 

177.

LLA-5c

ADHS's Director's Final Decision dated 01-26-2016

 12/15/16

 

 

 

178.

LLA-6a

HGFD Cover Ltr Response to Public Record Request FYE 06-30-2013

 

 

 X

 

179.

LLA-6b

HGFD Cover Ltr Response to Public Record Request FYE 06-30-2014

 

 

 X

 

180.

LLA-6c

HGFD Cover Ltr Response to Public Record Request FYE 06-30-2015

 

 

 X

 

181.

LLA-7a

HGFD annual reported financials FYE 06-30-2013

 12/12/16

 

 

 

182.

LLA-7b

HGFD annual reported financials FYE 06-30-2014

 12/13/16

 

 

 

183.

LLA-7c

HGFD annual reported financials FYE 06-30-2015

 12/13/16

 

 

 

184.

LLA-8a

HGFD Annual Budget - FYE 06-30-2013

 12/13/16

 

 

 

185.

LLA-8b

HGFD Annual Budget - FYE 06-30-2014

 12/13/16

 

 

 

186.

LLA-8c

HGFD Annual Budget - FYE 06-30-2015

 12/13/16

 

 

 

187.

LLA-9

AZ Fire Districts Tax Rates and CONs (2014 & 2015)

 12/16/16

 

 

 

188.

LLA-10a

2016-2017 Property Tax Levies & Tax Rates Ltr & Attachments (15 Aug 2016)

 12/13/16

 

 

 

189.

LLA-10b

2015-2016 Property Tax Levies & Tax Rates REVISED 9-15-15

 12/13/16

 

 

 

190.

LLA-10c

2014-2015 Property Tax Levies & TaxRates FINAL for TY2014

 12/13/16

 

 

 

191.

LLA-10d

2013-2014 Property Tax Rates & Tax Levies UPDATED TY 2013

 12/13/16

 

 

 

192.

LLA-10e

ARS 48-807(F) - County fire district assistance tax; annual budget; override

 

 

 X

 

193.

LLA-11

Arizona Daily Dispatch article dated 06-05-2016 re-Groom Creek Fire District

 12/16/16

 

 

 

194.

LLA-12a

CON No. 58 (Life Line)

 12/13/16

 

 

 

195.

LLA-12b

CON No. 81 (Pine-Strawberry FD)

 12/13/16

 

 

 

196.

LLA-12c

CON No. 112 (Tonto Basin FD)

 12/13/16

 

 

 

197.

LLA-12d

CON No. 126 (Tri-City FD)

 12/13/16

 

 

 

198.

LLA-13a

Doug Jones Resume

 12/15/16

 

 

 

199.

LLA-13b

Rich Bartus Resume

 12/15/16

 

 

 

200.

LLA-13c.

Glenn Kasprzyk ResumeAZ15

 12/16/16

 

 

 

201.

LLA-13d

Jeff Baker Bio Life Line Operations Mgr

 

 

 X

 

202.

LLA-13e

Edward Racht MD CV 2016

 12/15/16

 

 

 

203.

LLA-13f

Danny Brumbaugh Bio

 

 

 X

 

204.

LLA-13g

Jim Roeder - BIO

 12/15/16

 

 

 

205.

LLA-13h

John Valentine - CV

 12/15/16

 

 

 

206.

LLA-13i

John P Karolzak BIO

 

 

 X

 

207.

LLA-13j

Edwar Armijo - Resume

 

 

 X

 

208.

LLA-13k

Alan Maguire Bio

 12/15/16

 

 

 

209.

LLA-14

CON 58 & CITY OF PAYSON RESPONSE TIMES

 12/15/16

 

 

 

210.

LLA-15

Hellsgate ARCR Comparative Analysis

 12/12/16

 

 

 

211.

LLA-16

Hellsgate ARCR Comparative Analysis II (with detail)

 

 

 X

 

212.

LLA-17a

Maricopa County Calls in CON 58 ordered by date

 12/13/16

 

 

 

213.

LLA-17b

Calls East of CON 58 ordered by date

 12/13/16

 

 

 

214.

LLA-18

Banner Contract Submittal 07-27-2016

 12/16/16

 

 

 

215.

LLA-19

P-S Fire District needs budget override..

 12/13/16

 

 

 

216.

LLA-20

IAE&P letter to DHS 10-13-16

 12/15/16

 

 

 

217.

LLA-21a

CON No. 58 service area

 12/13/16

 

 

 

218.

LLA-21b

CON No. 58 wit overlapping CONs

 12/13/16

 

 

 

219.

LLA-21c

Hellsgate proposed, per Application (written description)

 12/13/16

 

 

 

220.

LLA-21d

Hellsgate proposed, per Application (per submitted map)

 12/13/16

 

 

 

221.

LLA-21e

Hellsgate porposed service area map, revised after substantive review

 12/13/16

 

 

 

222.

LLA-21f

Hellsgate proposed service area map, revised to exclude CON No. 109

 12/13/16

 

 

 

223.

LLA-21g

Hellsgate proposed service area map, revised to exclude all Maricopa County CONs

 12/13/16

 

 

 

224.

LLA-22

Hellsgate FD boundries & proposed CON service area

 12/13/16

 

 

 

225.

LLA-23a

Emails re - HGFD service area (ending 10-04-16 206PM

 

 

 X

 

226.

LLA-23b

Emails re - HGFD service area (ending 10-05-16 1028AM

 

 

 X

 

227.

LLA-24

AMR CON 136 Opposing Hellsgate (Director)1

 12/16/16

 

 

 

228.

LLA-27

Hellsgate ARCR Comparative Analysis 12.9.16

 12/15/16

 

 

 

 

      

 

 

5. Administrative Law Judge Decision and any Revisions or Modifications: A.R.S. § 12-904(B)(4)

 

Number

Document Number

Filing Date

Document Type

Description

Filed By

229.

64

4/28/2017

Administrative Law Judge Decision

Administrative Law Judge Decision

Webmaster on behalf of Self - Webmaster

230.

65 (Received on 7/14/2017. Posted this date by webmaster)

8/29/2017

Final Agency Action

Final Agency Action

Webmaster on behalf of Self - Webmaster

 

 

 

6. Transcript: A.R.S. § 12-904(B)(5)

 

Number

Document Number

Filing Date

Document Type

Description

Filed By

231.

51A

1/10/2017

Transcript

Hearing Transcript- December 12, 2016

Webmaster

232.

51B

1/10/2017

Transcript

Hearing Transcript- December 13, 2016

Webmaster

233.

51C

1/10/2017

Transcript

Hearing Transcript- December 14, 2016

Webmaster

234.

51D

1/10/2017

Transcript

Hearing Transcript- December 15, 2016

Webmaster

235.

51E

1/10/2017

Transcript

Hearing Transcript- December 16, 2016

Webmaster