State of Arizona Office of Administrative Hearings

Electronic Case File

13A-SW001-DWR
In the Matter of the Decision of the Director to Grant the Salt River Valley Water Users' Associations' Amended Applications Nos. E-11, R-30, R-45, R46, R-71, R-72, A-135 and A-136 for Permits to Store and Beneficially Use Water on the Salt and Verde Rivers and Issue Permits Nos. 33-11, 33-97001, 33-97002, 33-97003, 33-97004 and 33-97005


Document Number Filing Date Document Type Description Filed By
18/29/2013Request for HearingRequest for HearingWebmaster on behalf of Self - Webmaster
1a8/30/2013 -posted by WebmasterRequest for HearingNotice of HearingAgency - Sharon Scantlebury
29/5/2013Pre-Hearing OrderCASE MANAGEMENT ORDER No. 1Thomas Shedden on behalf of Self - Administrative Law Judge
39/5/2013Pre-Hearing OrderCASE MANAGEMENT ORDER No. 2Thomas Shedden on behalf of Self - Administrative Law Judge
49/5/2013Misc. Motion (specified in description)Motion for Summary JudgmentJohn B. Weldon on behalf of Salt River Valley Water Users' Associati - Applicant
59/5/2013Misc. Motion (specified in description)Statement of Facts in Support of its Motion for Summary JudgJohn B. Weldon on behalf of Salt River Valley Water Users' Associati - Appellant
69/5/2013Misc. Motion (specified in description)Motion for Summary Judgment re PalomaJohn B. Weldon on behalf of Salt River Valley Water Users Associatio - Applicant
79/5/2013Misc. Motion (specified in description)Statement of Facts re PalomaJohn B. Weldon on behalf of Salt River Valley Water Users' Associati - Applicant
89/6/2013Minute EntryMinute Entry No. 1Thomas Shedden on behalf of Self - Administrative Law Judge
99/6/2013Pre-Hearing OrderCASE MANAGEMENT ORDER No. 3Thomas Shedden on behalf of Self - Administrative Law Judge
109/6/2013Misc. Motion (specified in description)Salt River's Errata to Statement of Facts Re ArlingtonJohn Weldon on behalf of Salt River Valley Water Users' Ass. - Applicant
119/6/2013Attachments/Exhibits to Motion/PleadingExhibits to Salt River's Statement of Facts Re ArlingtonJohn B. Weldon on behalf of Salt River Valley Water Users' Assoc. - Applicant
129/6/2013Misc. Motion (specified in description)Salt River's Errata to MSJ Re PalomaJohn B. Weldon on behalf of Salt River Valley Water Users' Assoc. - Applicant
139/6/2013Misc. Motion (specified in description)Salt River's Errata to Statement of Facts Re PalomaJohn B. Weldon on behalf of Salt River Valley Water Users' Assoc. - Applicant
149/6/2013Misc. Motion (specified in description)Exhibits 1-10 to Salt River's Statement of Facts Re PalomaJohn B. Weldon on behalf of Salt River Valley Water Users' Assoc. - Applicant
159/6/2013Attachments/Exhibits to Motion/PleadingExhibits 11-18 to Salt River's Statement of Fact Re PalomaJohn B. Weldon on behalf of Salt River Valley Water Users' Assoc. - Applicant
169/11/2013Motion for Pre-Hearing ConferenceRequest for Prehearing Conference and ContinuanceKeith L. Hendricks on behalf of Appellants PIDD & Arlington Canal Co. - Appellant
179/11/2013Response to Misc. Motion (specified in description)Initial Response to MSJ and Request that it be RejectedKeith Hendricks on behalf of Appellant Arlington Canal Company - Appellant
189/11/2013Response to Misc. Motion (specified in description)Initial Response to MSJ and Request that it be RejectedKeith Hendricks on behalf of Appellant Paloma Irrigation & Drainage D - Appellant
199/12/2013Response to Misc. Motion (specified in description)SRVWUA's Response to Appellants' Alternative Request John B. Weldon on behalf of Salt River Valley Water Users' Assoc. - Applicant
209/13/2013Misc. Motion (specified in description)SRVWUA's Motion to Limit Issues to Proper Statutory ScopeJohn B. Weldon on behalf of Salt River Valley Water Users' Assoc. - Applicant
219/20/2013List of Witnesses and ExhibitsDWR's Initial List of Witnesses and ExhibitsSharon Scantlebury on behalf of Arizona Department of Water Resources - Agency
229/20/2013Response to Misc. Motion (specified in description)LG WATER USERS’ RESPONSE TO SRVWUA’S MOTION TO LIMIT ISSUESDonna Navarro on behalf of LG Water Users - Appellant
239/20/2013List of Witnesses and ExhibitsSRVWUA's List of Witnesses and ExhibitsJohn B. Weldon on behalf of Salt River Valley Water Users' Assoc. - Applicant
249/20/2013List of Witnesses and ExhibitsAppellant LG's Initial List of Witnesses & ExhibitsDonna Navarro on behalf of LG Water Users - Appellant
259/23/2013Denying Misc. MotionCASE MANAGEMENT ORDER No. 4Thomas Shedden on behalf of Self - Administrative Law Judge
269/23/2013Motions in LimineSRVWUA's Motion in Limine to Preclude Testimony by LGWU's John B. Weldon on behalf of Salt River Valley Water Users' Assoc. - Applicant
279/27/2013Misc. NoticeAppellants LG Water Users' Notice of Filing ExhibitsDonna M. Navarro on behalf of LG Water Users - Appellant
289/27/2013Misc. NoticeDWR's Notice of Filing ExhibitsSharon Scantlebury on behalf of Department of Water Resources - Agency
28a9/27/2013, deactivated 10/17/2013, see 45aExhibitsElectronic Posting of SRVWUA's ExhibitsWebmaster - self
28b9/27/2013, deactivated 10/17/2013, see 45aExhibitsElectronic Posting of LG Water User's ExhibitsWebmaster - self
299/30/2013Response to Motions in LimineResponse to SRVWUA's Motion to Exclude WitnessesDonna Navarro on behalf of LG Water Users - Appellant
309/30/2013Request for HearingAppellant's Request for a Prehearing ConferenceDonna Navarro on behalf of LG Water Users - Appellant
319/30/2013Misc. NoticeNotice of Posting of ExhibitsWebmaster on behalf of self - Webmaster
329/30/2013Pre-Hearing OrderCASE MANAGEMENT ORDER No. 5Thomas Shedden on behalf of Self - Administrative Law Judge
32a10/1/2013, deactivated 10/17/2013, see 45aExhibitsElectronic Posting of DWR ExhibitsWebmaster - self
3310/1/2013Misc. NoticeNotice of posting exhibitsWebmaster on behalf of self - Webmaster
3410/4/2013Pre-Hearing MemorandumDWR's Pre-Hearing MemorandumSharon Scantlebury on behalf of Department of Water Resources - Agency
3510/4/2013Pre-Hearing MemorandumSRVWUA's Pre-Hearing MemorandumJohn B. Weldon on behalf of Salt River Valley Water Users' Assoc. - Applicant
3610/4/2013Motions in LimineMotion in Limine re Determination of Vested Water RightsDonna Navarro on behalf of LG Water Users - Appellant
3710/4/2013Pre-Hearing MemorandumLG Water Users' Prehearing BriefDonna Navarro on behalf of LG Water Users - Appellant
3810/10/2013Request for SubpoenasRequest for Subpoenas for Appearance at Evidentiary HearingJosh Greer on behalf of LG Water Users - Appellant
3910/10/2013Response to Motions in LimineSRVWUA's Response to Appellant's Motion in Limine John B. Weldon on behalf of Salt River Valley Water Users' Assoc. - Applicant
4010/11/2013Posting of Signed SubpoenasPosting of Signed SubpoenasWebmaster on behalf of self - Webmaster
4110/11/2013Response to Motions in LimineDWR's Response to LG Water Users Motion in Limine re DetermSharon Scantlebury on behalf of Department of Water Resources - Agency
4210/11/2013Affidavit of ServiceAffidavit of Service of Subpoena on DWRL. Carol Smith on behalf of LG Water Users - Appellant
4310/11/2013Affidavit of ServiceAffidavit of Service of Subpoena on SRVWUAL. Carol Smith on behalf of LG Water Users - Appellant
4410/15/2013Denying Misc. MotionCASE MANAGEMENT ORDER No. 6Thomas Shedden on behalf of Self - Administrative Law Judge
4510/15/2013Misc. Motion (specified in description)Joint Motion to Quash SubpoenasNicole D Klobas on behalf of DWR - Agency
45a10/17/2013- Updated by Webmaster on 2/20/14; Updated by Webmaster on 2/26/14;Updated by Webmaster on 2/27/14ExhibitsElectronic Posting of Combined Exhibits (separate exhibit list deactivated)Webmaster - self
4610/17/2013Misc. NoticeNotice of Posting of Combined Exhibit ListWebmaster on behalf of self - Webmaster
4710/17/2013Misc. NoticeSRVWUA's Notice of Filing Replacement ExhibitsJohn B. Weldon on behalf of Salt River Valley Water Users' Assoc. - Applicant
4810/17/2013Request for SubpoenasRequest for SubpoenasL. Carol Smith on behalf of LG Water Users - Appellant
48a10/17/2013Audio RecordPre-Hearing Audio October 7, 2013Webmaster
4910/17/2013Misc. NoticePosting if Pre-hearing Audio RecordWebmaster on behalf of Self - Webmaster
5010/18/2013Posting of Signed SubpoenasNotice of Posting of Signed Subpoenas submitted by LG Webmaster on behalf of self - Webmaster
5110/18/2013Misc. NoticeSRVWUA's Notice of Filing Exhibit SR-287John B. Weldon on behalf of Salt River Valley Water Users' Assoc. - Applicant
5210/18/2013Misc. NoticeNotice of posting exhibitsWebmaster on behalf of self - Webmaster
5310/18/2013Minute EntryMinute Entry No. 2Thomas Shedden on behalf of Self - Administrative Law Judge
5410/18/2013Affidavit of ServiceAcceptance of Service of Subpoenas for HearingL. Carol Smith on behalf of LG Water Users - Appellant
5510/18/2013Response to Misc. Motion (specified in description)Response to Joint Motion to QuashL. Carol Smith on behalf of LG Water Users - Appellant
5610/18/2013Affidavit of ServiceAcceptance of Service of Subpoenas for HearingL. Carol Smith on behalf of LG Water Users - Appellant
5710/18/2013Misc. NoticeNotice of posting exhibitsWebmaster on behalf of self - Webmaster
5810/18/2013Granting Misc. MotionCASE MANAGEMENT ORDER No. 7Thomas Shedden on behalf of Self - Administrative Law Judge
5910/18/2013ExhibitsAppellant's LG Water Users Notice of Filing ExhibitsL. Carol Smith on behalf of LG Water Users - Appellant
6010/20/2013Misc. NoticeNotice of Filing ExhibitNicole D. Klobas on behalf of DWR - Agency
6110/21/2013Misc. NoticeNotice of posting exhibitsWebmaster on behalf of self - Webmaster
6210/21/2013Misc. NoticeNotice of Filing ExhibitsL. Carol Smith on behalf of LG Water Users - Appellant
6310/22/2013Affidavit of ServiceAcceptance of Service of Subpoena for HearingL. Carol Smith on behalf of LG Water Users - Appellant
63a10/22/2013Audio RecordHearing Audio October 21, 2013Webmaster
6410/23/2013Misc. NoticeNotice of Posting ExhibitsWebmaster on behalf of Self - Webmaster
64a10/23/2013Audio RecordHearing Audio October 22, 2013Webmaster
64b10/24/2013Audio RecordHearing Audio October 23, 2013Webmaster
6510/24/2013Misc. NoticeNotice of Filing ExhibitsL. Carol Smith on behalf of LG Water Users - Appellant
6610/24/2013Misc. NoticeNotice of Posting ExhibitsWebmaster on behalf of Self - Webmaster
6710/25/2013Misc. NoticeNotice of Posting ExhibitsWebmaster on behalf of Self - Webmaster
67a10/25/2013Audio RecordHearing Audio October 24, 2013Webmaster
6810/25/2013Misc. NoticeSRVWUA's Notice of Filing Replacement ExhibitsJohn B. Weldon on behalf of Salt River Valley Water Users' Assoc. - Applicant
6910/25/2013Misc. NoticeNotice of Posting Replacement ExhibitsWebmaster on behalf of Self - Webmaster
7010/28/2013Misc. OrderCASE MANAGEMENT ORDER No. 8Thomas Shedden on behalf of Self - Administrative Law Judge
70a10/30/2013Audio RecordHearing Audio October 25, 2013Webmaster
7111/6/2013Request for SubpoenasREQUEST FOR SUBPOENA FOR DOCUMENTSDonna Navarro on behalf of LG Water Users - Appellant
7211/7/2013Misc. OrderCASE MANAGEMENT ORDER No. 9Thomas Shedden on behalf of Self - Administrative Law Judge
7311/11/2013Request for SubpoenasRequest for SubpoenaL. Carol Smith on behalf of LG Water Users - Appellant
7411/11/2013Request for SubpoenasRequest for SubpoenaL. Carol Smith on behalf of LG Water Users - Appellant
7511/12/2013Response to Misc. Motion (specified in description)Response to LGWUS' Request for Subpoena for DocumentsMark A. McGinnis on behalf of SRVWUA - Applicant
75a11/13/2013TranscriptVolume I- October 21, 2013Webmaster on behalf of Self - Webmaster
75b11/13/2013TranscriptVolume II- October 22, 2013Webmaster on behalf of Self - Webmaster
75c11/13/2013TranscriptVolume III- October 23, 2013Webmaster on behalf of Self - Webmaster
75d11/13/2013TranscriptVolume IV- October 24, 2013Webmaster on behalf of Self - Webmaster
75e11/13/2013TranscriptVolume V- October 25, 2013Webmaster on behalf of Self - Webmaster
7611/15/2013Misc. OrderCASE MANAGEMENT ORDER No. 10Thomas Shedden on behalf of Self - Administrative Law Judge
7711/19/2013Response to Misc. Motion (specified in description)LG Water Users' Response to SRVWUA's Motion to QuashDonna Navarro on behalf of LG Water Users - Appellant
7811/19/2013Response to Misc. Motion (specified in description)DWR's Response to Issues Raised in SRVWUA ResponseSharon Scantlebury on behalf of Department of Water Resources - Agency
7911/21/2013Denying Misc. MotionCASE MANAGEMENT ORDER No. 11Thomas Shedden on behalf of Self - Administrative Law Judge
8012/3/2013List of Witnesses and ExhibitsSupplemental List of WitnessesL. Carol Smith on behalf of LG Water Users - Appellant
8112/5/2013Misc. Motion (specified in description)Stipulation Regarding Scope of Issue No. 2John B. Weldon on behalf of Salt River Valley Water Users' Assoc. - Appellant
8212/6/2013Motions in LimineSRVWUA's Motion in Limine to Preclude Testimony by C. DumarsJohn B. Weldon on behalf of Salt River Valley Water Users' Assoc. - Appellant
8312/10/2013Misc. Motion (specified in description)DWR's Joinder in SRVWUA's Motion in Limine to Preclude TestiSharon Scantlebury on behalf of Department of Water Resources - Agency
8412/11/2013Misc. NoticeSRVWUA's Notice of Filing Replacement ExhibitsJohn B. Weldon on behalf of Salt River Valley Water Users' Assoc. - Appellant
8512/12/2013Misc. NoticeNotice of Substitution of ExhibitsWebmaster on behalf of self - Webmaster
8612/13/2013Response to Motions in LimineLG WATER USERS’ RESPONSE TO SRVWUA’S MOTION IN LIMINE Donna Navarro on behalf of Appellant LG Water Users - Appellant
8712/13/2013ExhibitsNotice of Filing ExhibitsL. Carol Smith on behalf of LG Water Users - Appellant
8812/16/2013Misc. NoticePosting of LG Exhibits 100-107 to Combined Exhibit ListWebmaster on behalf of Self - Webmaster
8912/17/2013Misc. NoticeSRVWUA's Notice of Filing Replacement ExhibitJohn B. Weldon on behalf of Salt River Valley Water Users' Assoc. - Appellant
9012/17/2013Denying Misc. MotionCASE MANAGEMENT ORDER No. 12Thomas Shedden on behalf of Self - Administrative Law Judge
9112/18/2013ExhibitsNotice of Filing ExhibitsL. Carol Smith on behalf of LG Water Users - Appellant
9212/18/2013Misc. NoticePosting of Substitute Exhibitwebmaster on behalf of selj - Webmaster
9312/19/2013Misc. NoticeNotice of Filing Replacement ExhibitsL. Carol Smith on behalf of LG Water Users - Appellant
93a12/19/2013Audio RecordHearing Audio December 16, 2013Webmaster
93b12/19/2013Audio RecordHearing Audio December 17, 2013Webmaster
93c12/19/2013Audio RecordHearing Audio December 18, 2013Webmaster
9412/23/2013Request for SubpoenasRequest for SubpoenasL. Carol Smith on behalf of LG Water Users - Appellant
9512/23/2013Posting of Signed SubpoenasPosting of signed subpoena for SRVWUAWebmaster on behalf of webmaster - Webmaster
9612/23/2013Posting of Denied SubpoenasPosting of denied subpoena for G. Ten Eyck;L.R EngineersWebmaster on behalf of webmaster - Webmaster
96a12/24/2013Audio RecordHearing Audio December 19, 2013Webmaster
96b12/24/2013Audio RecordHearing Audio December 20, 2013Webmaster
9712/26/2013Misc. OrderCASE MANAGEMENT ORDER No. 13Thomas Shedden on behalf of Self - Administrative Law Judge
981/6/2014Misc. NoticeSRVWUA's Notice of Filing Replacement ExhibitJohn B. Weldon on behalf of Salt River Valley Water Users' Assoc. - Appellant
991/9/2014Misc. NoticePosting of Replacement Exhibit SRVWUA-84 to Hearing ExhibitsWebmaster on behalf of self - Webmaster
99a1/9/2014TranscriptsDecember 16-20, 2013 transcriptWebmaster on behalf of self - Webmaster
1001/24/2014Misc. NoticeNotice of posting of transcriptsWebmaster on behalf of self - Webmaster
1012/13/2014List of Witnesses and ExhibitsLG Water Users' Second Supplemental Disclosure of WitnessesL. Carol Smith on behalf of LG Water Users - Appellant
1022/14/2014List of Witnesses and ExhibitsSupplemental List of WitnessesJohn B. Weldon on behalf of Salt River Valley Water Users' Associati - Appellant
1032/20/2014List of Witnesses and ExhibitsSRVWUA's Supplemental List of ExhibitsJohn B. Weldon on behalf of Salt River Valley Water Users' Assoc. - Appellant
1042/20/2014Misc. NoticePosting of Exhibits SR-303 through SR-332Webmaster on behalf of Self - Webmaster
1052/24/2014ExhibitsAppellant LG Water Users' Notice of Filing ExhibitsL. Carol Smith on behalf of LG Water Users - Appellant
1062/25/2014Misc. NoticeNotice of Posting Exhibits LG111-LG115Webmaster on behalf of self - Webmaster
1072/25/2014Misc. NoticeSRVWUA's Notice of Filing ExhibitsJohn B. Weldon on behalf of Salt River Valley Water Users' Assoc. - Appellant
1082/26/2014ExhibitsNotice of Filing ExhibitsL. Carol Smith on behalf of LG Water Users - Appellant
1092/26/2014ExhibitsNotice of Filing ExhibitL. Carol Smith on behalf of LG Water Users - Appellant
1102/26/2014ExhibitsNotice of Filing ExhibitL. Carol Smith on behalf of LG Water Users - Appellant
110a2/26/2014Audio RecordHearing Audio February 26, 2014Webmaster
110b2/27/2014Audio RecordHearing Audio February 27, 2014Webmaster
1113/2/2014Misc. NoticeSRVWUA's Notice of Filing Exhibits John B. Weldon on behalf of Salt River Valley Water Users' Assoc. - Appellant
1123/3/2014Misc. NoticeNotice of Posting of SRVWUA 336-338Webmaster on behalf of self - Webmaster
1133/3/2014Misc. NoticeNotice of Posting of SRVWUA 336-338Webmaster on behalf of self - Webmaster
113a3/3/2014Audio RecordHearing Audio February 28, 2014Webmaster
1143/4/2014ExhibitsNotice of Filing ExhibitsL. Carol Smith on behalf of LG Water Users - Appellant
1153/4/2014Misc. NoticePosting of LG118-123 to Hearing ExhibitsWebmaster on behalf of self - Webmaster
115a3/4/2014Audio RecordHearing Audio March 3, 2014Webmaster
115b3/4/2014Audio RecordHearing Audio March 4, 2014 Part 1Webmaster
1163/5/2014Misc. OrderCASE MANAGEMENT ORDER No. 14Thomas Shedden on behalf of Self - Administrative Law Judge
116a3/4/2014Audio RecordHearing Audio March 4, 2014 Part 2Webmaster
116b03/25/14TranscriptVolume XI Transcript- February 26, 2014Webmaster on behalf of Self - Webmaster
116c03/25/14TranscriptVolume XII Transcript- February 27, 2014Webmaster on behalf of Self - Webmaster
116d03/25/14TranscriptVolume VIII Transcript- February 28, 2014Webmaster on behalf of Self - Webmaster
116e03/25/14TranscriptVolume XIV Transcript- March 3, 2014Webmaster on behalf of Self - Webmaster
116f03/25/14TranscriptVolume XV Transcript- March 4, 2014Webmaster on behalf of Self - Webmaster
1175/19/2014Post-Hearing MemorandumSRVWUA'S CLOSING ARGUMENTJohn B. Weldon on behalf of Salt River Valley Water Users Associatio - Appellant
1185/19/2014Proposed Findings of Fact and Conclusions of LawSRVWUA'S PROPOSED FINDINGS OF FACT AND CONCLUSIONS OF LAWJohn B. Weldon on behalf of Salt River Valley Water Users Associatio - Appellant
1195/19/2014Proposed Findings of Fact and Conclusions of LawProposed Findings of Facts and Conclusion of LawDonna Navarro on behalf of LG Water Users - Appellant
1205/19/2014Post-Hearing MemorandumLG Water Users' Closing ArgumentsDonna Navarro on behalf of LG Water Users - Appellant
1215/19/2014Post-Hearing MemorandumFindings of Fact, Closing Argt and Conclusions of LawJanet L. Miller on behalf of Ariz. Dept of Water Resources - Agency
1226/23/2014Post-Hearing MemorandumLG WATER USERS’ RESPONSE TO APPLICANT’S BRIEFDonna Navarro on behalf of LG Water Users - Appellant
1236/23/2014Post-Hearing MemorandumSRVWUA's Response BriefJohn B. Weldon on behalf of SRVWUA - Appellant
1246/23/2014Post-Hearing MemorandumLG WATER USERS’ RESPONSE TO DWR’S WRITTEN CLOSINGDonna Navarro on behalf of LG Water Users - Appellant
1256/23/2014Post-Hearing MemorandumSRVWUA's Responses and Objections to LGWAJohn B. Weldon on behalf of SRVWUA - Appellant
1266/23/2014Post-Hearing MemorandumResponse BriefJanet L. Miller on behalf of AZ. Dept of Water Resources - Agency
1276/25/2014Post-Hearing MemorandumNotice of ErrataJanet L. Miller on behalf of Ariz. Dept. of Water Resources - Agency
1287/1/2014Post-Hearing MemorandumLGWU Notice of Errata re Written Closing & Proposed FindingsDonna Navarro on behalf of LG Water Users - Appellant
1299/2/2014Administrative Law Judge DecisionPosting of ALJ Recommended DecisionWebmaster on behalf of Self - Webmaster
13010/1/2014Final Agency ActionDecision and Order of the DirectorSharon Scantlebury on behalf of The Department of Water Resources - Agency
13111/4/2014Notice of AppealNotice of Appeal of Agency DecisionL. Carol Smith on behalf of LG Water Users - Appellant
13211/6/2014Notice of AppealAMENDED NOTICE OF LG WATER USERS’ APPEAL OF AGENCY DECISIONDonna Navarro on behalf of LG Water Users - Appellant
13312/4/2014Certification of RecordCertification of Recordwebmaster on behalf of self - Webmaster

Click here to file a document in this matter.
(Parties only - Password required)