State of Arizona Office of Administrative Hearings

Electronic Case File

12A-AWS001-DWR
In the Matter of the Decision of the Director to Grant Pueblo Del Sol Water Company's Application for Designation as Having an Adequate Water Supply No. 40-700705.0000


Filing Date Document Type Description Filed By
9/4/2012 Posted by Webmaster 9/24/2012Notice of HearingNotice of HearingJanet L. Ronald, - ADWR
9/14/2012 Posted by Webmaster 9/24/2012Pre-Hearing OrderOrder Setting Filing deadlinesThomas Shedden - Administrative Law Judge
9/21/2012 Posted by Webmaster 9/24/2012Misc. Motion (specified in description)Stipulated Motion Re: Hearing Date and Filing DeadlinesJohn Gaudio- Appellant
9/24/2012Pre-Hearing OrderCASE MANAGEMENT ORDER No. 1Administrative Law Judge - Thomas Shedden
9/24/2012Pre-Hearing OrderCASE MANAGEMENT ORDER No. 2Administrative Law Judge - Thomas Shedden
10/2/2012 (corrected from 10/4/2012, previously reflected)Agency RecordAgency Record received 9/21/2012 and republished in pdf (see misc notice for limitations)Webmaster - Webmaster
10/2/2012Misc. NoticeAdvisement regarding posting of agency recordWebmaster - Webmaster
10/9/2012Misc. Motion (specified in description)MOTION TO COMPLETE RECORDAppellant - ROBIN SILVER
10/9/2012ExhibitsUSGS Open-File Report, Evaluation of SimulationsAppellant - Patricia Gerrodette
10/9/2012Technical Bulletintest submissionWebmaster - Webmaster
10/10/2012Response to Misc. Motion (specified in description)ADWR's Response to Motion to Complete Administrative RecordAgency - Sharon Scantlebury
10/22/2012List of Witnesses and ExhibitsList of WitnessesAppellant - Patricia Gerrodette
10/22/2012List of Witnesses and ExhibitsEXHIBIT LISTS FOR ROBIN SILVER MDAppellant - ROBIN SILVER MD
10/22/2012List of Witnesses and ExhibitsWITNESS LIST FOR ROBIN SILVER MDAppellant - ROBIN SILVER MD
10/22/2012List of Witnesses and ExhibitsADWRs' Initial List of WitnessesAgency - Sharon Scantlebury
10/22/2012List of Witnesses and ExhibitsADWRs' Initial List of ExhibitsAgency - Sharon Scantlebury
10/22/2012List of Witnesses and ExhibitsList of ExhibitsAppellant - Patricia Gerrodette
10/22/2012List of Witnesses and ExhibitsList of Witnesses and ExhibitsApplicant - William P. Sullivan
10/22/2012List of Witnesses and ExhibitsBureau of Land Management's Lists of Witnesses and ExhibitsAppellant - John Gaudio
10/23/2012Pre-Hearing OrderCASE MANAGEMENT ORDER No. 3Administrative Law Judge - Thomas Shedden
10/23/2012Pre-Hearing Memorandumquestion about paper copies of exhibitsAppellant - Patricia Gerrodette
10/23/2012List of Witnesses and ExhibitsPDS Amended List of Witnesses and ExhibitsApplicant - William Sullivan
10/24/2012Minute EntryMinute Entry No. 1Administrative Law Judge - Thomas Shedden
10/24/2012, updated 11/26/2012 by Webmaster to add Silver exhibit 36Posting of Silver ExhibitsSilver Exhibits 1-35, delivered to OAH 10/24/2012Webmaster - Webmaster
10/24/2012Misc. NoticeAdvisement of Posting exhibitsWebmaster - Webmaster
10/24/2012Pre-Hearing OrderCASE MANAGEMENT ORDER No. 4Administrative Law Judge - Thomas Shedden
10/25/2012List of Witnesses and ExhibitsPatricia Gerrodette's First Amended List of ExhibitsAppellant - Patricia Gerrodette
10/29/2012List of Witnesses and ExhibitsBLM's First Amended List of ExhibitsAppellant - John Gaudio
10/29/2012Notice of Pre-Submission of Exhibits (CD with index live links to documents)ADWR's Notice of Filing ExhibitsAgency - Sharon Scantlebury
10/29/2012Notice of Pre-Submission of Exhibits (CD with index live links to documents)Pueblo del Sol's Notice of Filing ExhibitsApplicant - William Sullivan
10/29/2012Notice of Pre-Submission of Exhibits (CD with index live links to documents)BLM's Notice of Filing ExhibitsAppellant - John Gaudio
10/29/2012Posting of Guerrodette Exhibits Gerrodette's Exhibits Webmaster - Webmaster
10/29/2012Posting of Guerrodette Exhibits First AmendedGerrodette's Exhibits (First Amended)Webmaster - Webmaster
10/29/2012Posting of BLM's ExhibitsBLM's ExhibitsWebmaster - Webmaster
10/29/2012Posting of ADWR's ExhibitsADWR's ExhibitsWebmaster - Webmaster
10/29/2012Posting of Pueblo's ExhibitsPueblo del Sol's ExhibitsWebmaster - Webmaster
10/29/2012, updated 11/26/2012 by Webmaster to add Silver exhibit 36; updated by Webmaster 12/7/2012 to reflect status of exhibitsPosting of Combined ExhibitsCombined Exhibit ListWebmaster - Webmaster
10/30/2012Misc. NoticeNotice of Electronic Posting of Exhibits to Website Webmaster - Webmaster
11/5/2012Pre-Hearing MemorandumADWRs' Pre-Hearing MemorandumAgency - Sharon Scantlebury
11/5/2012Misc. Motion (specified in description)Pueblo del Sol Motion to DismissApplicant - William Sullivan
11/5/2012Misc. Motion (specified in description)Pueblo del Sol Request for Witness SummaryApplicant - William Sullivan
11/5/2012Motions in LiminePueblo del Sol Motion in LimineApplicant - William Sullivan
11/5/2012Motion to VacateGerrodette's Motion to Vacate HearingAppellant - Patricia Gerrodette
11/8/2012Misc. NoticeADWRs' Pre-Hearing Memorandum Notice of ErrataAgency - Sharon Scantlebury
11/9/2012Pre-Hearing OrderCASE MANAGEMENT ORDER No. 5Administrative Law Judge - Thomas Shedden
11/14/2012Response to Motion to VacatePueblo del Sol Response to Motion to Vacate HearingApplicant - William Sullivan
11/14/2012Response to Motion to VacateADWR's Response to Gerrodette's Motion to Vacate HearingAgency - Sharon Scantlebury
11/14/2012Response to Misc. Motion (specified in description)BLM's Consolidated Response to Motion to Dismiss Appeals, MoAppellant - John Gaudio
11/14/2012, posted by Webmaster 11/15/2012 due to party's stated technical difficulty in posting 11/14/2012 Response to Misc. Motion (specified in description)Response to Motion PG Nov.14Appellant - Patricia Gerrodette
11/15/2012Response to Misc. Motion (specified in description)Motion Opposing PDS' Motion to Dismiss/Witness INFOAppellant - ROBIN SILVER, M.D.
11/15/2012Misc. NoticeAdvisement of PostingWebmaster - Webmaster
11/15/2012Response to Misc. Motion (specified in description)MOTION TO CORRECT ADDITIONAL WITNESS INFOAppellant - ROBIN SILVER, M.D.
11/21/2012List of Witnesses and ExhibitsBLM's First Amended List of WitnessesAppellant - John Gaudio
11/21/2012Misc. Motion (specified in description)MOTION TO INCLUDE STUDY QUANTIFYING PDS TAKING OF BLM WATERAppellant - ROBIN SILVER, M.D.
11/21/2012Misc. Motion (specified in description)MOTION TO AMEND EXHIBIT LISTAppellant - ROBIN SILVER, M.D.
11/21/2012ExhibitsUSGS STUDY QUANTIFYING PDS� WATER TAKEN FROM BLMAppellant - ROBIN SILVER, M.D.
11/21/2012Notice of AppearanceGerrodette's Notice of Limited RepresentationAppellant - Patricia Gerrodette
11/21/2012Misc. Motion (specified in description)COMPLETE MOTION TO AMENDED EXHIBIT LISTAppellant - ROBIN SILVER, M.D.
11/23/2012Pre-Hearing OrderCASE MANAGEMENT ORDER No. 6Administrative Law Judge - Thomas Shedden
11/26/2012Misc. NoticePosting of Supplemental ExhibitWebmaster - webmaster
11/28/2012- see Technical Bulletin dated 11/28/12Audio RecordHearing Audio November 26, 2012

Webmaster
11/28/2012- see Technical Bulletin dated 11/28/12Audio RecordHearing Audio November 27, 2012

Webmaster
11/28/2012Technical BulletinNotice of Posting of Audio Recordings of Proceedings Webmaster - Webmaster
11/29/2012- see Technical Bulletin dated 11/28/12Audio RecordHearing Audio November 28, 2012

Webmaster
11/29/2012- see Technical Bulletin dated 11/28/12Audio RecordPart 1- Hearing Audio November 29, 2012

Webmaster
11/29/2012- see Technical Bulletin dated 11/28/12Audio RecordPart 2- Hearing Audio November 29, 2012

Webmaster
11/29/2012- see Technical Bulletin dated 11/28/12Audio RecordPart 3- Hearing Audio November 29, 2012

Webmaster
11/29/2012Misc. NoticeListing of Inaudible portions of Hearing RecordWebmaster - Webmaster
11/30/2012ExhibitsNotice of Filing Supplemental ExhibitApplicant - William Sullivan
11/30/2012- see Technical Bulletin dated 11/28/12Audio RecordPart 1- Hearing Audio November 30, 2012

Webmaster
11/30/2012Misc. NoticePosting of Supplemental Exhibit PDS-15Webmaster - Webmaster
12/3/2012- see Technical Bulletin dated 11/28/12Audio RecordPart 2- Hearing Audio November 30, 2012

Webmaster
12/3/2012Audio RecordWAV Formats of Hearing Audio Records

Webmaster
12/3/2012Misc. NoticePosting of Audio Hearing Records in WAV format.Webmaster - Webmaster
12/5/2012Post-Hearing OrderCASE MANAGEMENT ORDER No. 7Administrative Law Judge - Thomas Shedden
12/7/2012Misc. Motion (specified in description)Joint Motion to Vacate and Reset DeadlinesAgency - Sharon Scantlebury
12/7/2012Misc. NoticeAdvisement of update of combined exhibit list Webmaster - Webmaster
12/10/2012Post-Hearing OrderCASE MANAGEMENT ORDER No. 8Administrative Law Judge - Thomas Shedden
12/11/2012Misc. Motion (specified in description)BLM's Motion to Reconsider Admitting Exhibit RS-23 Into EvidAppellant - John Gaudio
12/14/2012Response to Misc. Motion (specified in description)DWR Response in Opposition to BLMs Motion to Reconsider AdmiAgency - Sharon Scantlebury
12/17/2012Response to Misc. Motion (specified in description)PDS Response in Opposition to BLM's Motion to Reconsider AdmApplicant - William Sullivan
12/31/2012Post-Hearing OrderCASE MANAGEMENT ORDER No. 9Administrative Law Judge - Thomas Shedden
1/25/2013Misc. NoticeJoint Notice and Stipulation Regarding Hearing TranscriptApplicant - William Sullivan
1/30/2013Misc. NoticeNotice of Filing Spreadsheet and Corrections to Exhibit ListApplicant - William Sullivan
2/8/2013Post-Hearing MemorandumBLM's Post-Hearing Brief Appellant - John Gaudio
2/8/2013Misc. Motion (specified in description)FINAL MOTIONAppellant - ROBIN SILVER
2/8/2013Post-Hearing MemorandumPDS Post Hearing BriefApplicant - William Sullivan
2/8/2013Post-Hearing MemorandumDWR's Post-Hearing MemorandumAgency - Janet L. Ronald
2/8/2013Post-Hearing MemorandumAppellant Patricia Gerrodette's Post-Hearing Closing BriefAppellant - Patricia Gerrodette
2/11/2013TranscriptTranscript November 26, 2012 Vol.1Webmaster
2/11/2013TranscriptTranscript November 27, 2012 Vol.2Webmaster
2/11/2013TranscriptTranscript November 28, 2012 Vol.3Webmaster
2/11/2013TranscriptTranscript November 29, 2012 Vol.4Webmaster
2/11/2013TranscriptTranscript November 30, 2012 Vol.5Webmaster
2/11/2013Technical BulletinWebmaster's Advisement- TranscriptsWebmaster - Webmaster
3/1/2013Order Closing RecordCASE MANAGEMENT ORDER No. 10Administrative Law Judge - Thomas Shedden
3/13/2013ALJ Recommended DecisionALJ Recommended DecisionWebmaster - Webmaster
3/14/2013Technical BulletinWebmaster's Advisement- Posting of ALJ Recommended DecisionWebmaster - Webmaster
4/18/2013Final Agency ActionFinal Agency ActionWebmaster - Webmaster
4/18/2013Misc. NoticeWebmaster's Advisement- Posting of Final Agency ActionWebmaster - Webmaster
5/28/2013Misc. NoticeGerrodette Notice of ActionAppellant - Patricia Gerrodette
5/28/2013Misc. Motion (specified in description)Notice of Filing Complaint for Judicial Review of Adm. Dec.Appellant - Robin Silver
6/3/2013Misc. NoticeBLM's Notice of ActionAppellant - John Gaudio
7/24/2013Misc. NoticeNoticeApplicant - William Sullivan

Click here to file a document in this matter.
(Parties only - Password required)