Cliff J. Vanell, Director
Office of Administrative Hearings
1400 West Washington, Suite 101
Phoenix, Arizona 85007
Telephone Number: 602-542-9826
E-mail: Cliff.vanell@azoah.com
IN THE SUPERIOR COURT OF THE STATE OF ARIZONA
IN AND FOR THE COUNTY OF MARICOPA
                       
UNITED STATES OF AMERICA U.S. DEPARTMENT OF THE INTERIOR BUREAU OF LAND MANAGEMENT  
LC2013-000271-001 DT
V
CERTIFICATION OF RECORD ON REVIEW
SANDRA A FABRITZ-WHITNEY RECORD OF ADMINISTRATIVE HEARING
ARIZONA DEPARTMENT OF WATER RESOURCES
PUEBLO DEL SOL WATER COMPANY OAH No. 12A-AWS001-DWR
PATRICIA GERRODETTE
ROBIN SILVER
     
CERTIFICATION OF RECORD ON REVIEW
            The undersigned, pursuant to Rule 5(a) Rules of Procedure for Judicial Review of Administrative Decisions, and pursuant to A.R.S.  12-904(B), hereby files with the Clerk of the Superior Court, the ORIGINAL record and exhibits, and an electronic copy, in CD form, of the prior administrative hearing in the above entitled matter.  This Court and the parties are advised that the Office of Administrative Hearings does not maintain a copy of this original record.
            Done this ___ day of June, 2013.
                                                                       
                                                                        _________________________________
                                                                        Jan Bacich
                                                                        Custodian of the Records
A F F I D A V I T
STATE OF ARIZONA         )
                                            )
COUNTY OF MARICOPA   )
          Cliff Vanell, being first duly sworn upon his oath deposes and says:
          He is the duly appointed Director of the Office of Administrative Hearings for the State of Arizona and that Jan Bacich is custodian of its records and as such is authorized to search the files of the agency and to execute the attached affidavit and/or certification.
            The attached document bears the true and genuine signature of the employee whose name appears thereon.
            WITNESS MY HAND AND SEAL OF THIS OFFICE this ______day of
June, 2013.
                                                            ___________________________________
                                                            CLIFF VANELL
                                                            OFFICE OF ADMINISTRATIVE HEARINGS
Subscribed and Sworn to before me
this _____ day of June , 2013.
___________________________________
NOTARY PUBLIC
My Commission Expires:_______________________
                                                                       
A copy of the INDEX of RECORD on REVIEW and documents,
CD containing electronic version of the record delivered this day of June, 201 to:
Maricopa County Superior Court
101/201 West Jefferson (ECB-CCB)
Phoenix, Arizona 85003-2205
A copy of the INDEX of RECORD on REVIEW,
Emailed/mailed on this _____ day of June, 2013 to:
Honorable Crane McClennen
Maricopa County Superior Court
101/201 West Jefferson (ECB-CCB)
Phoenix, Arizona 85003-2205
Arizona Department of Water Resources
Sandra Fabritz-Whitney
Arizona Department of Water Resources
Janet Ronald
Curtis, Goodwin, Sullivan, Udall & Schwab, P.L.C.
William P. Sullivan
United States Department of Interior
Julie A. Decker, Deputy State Director
Bureau of Land Management, Appellant
Arizona State Office
U.S. Department of the Interior Office of the Solicitor
Michael Gheleta
John Gauido
Patricia Gerrodette
Center for Biological Diversity
Cyndi Tuell, Esq.
By Jan Bacich    
INDEX of RECORD on REVIEW
Superior Court No. LC2013-000264
A.  Notice of Appeal
1 5/28/2013 Misc. Notice Gerrodette Notice of Action Appellant - Patricia Gerrodette
2 5/28/2013 Misc. Motion (specified in description) Notice of Filing Complaint for Judicial Review of Adm. Dec. Appellant - Robin Silver
B.  Original Agency Action From Which Review is Sought: A.R.S. 12-904(B)(1)
3 9/4/2012 Notice of Hearing Notice of Hearing Janet L. Ronald, - ADWR
C.  Motions, Memoranda or Other Documents Submitted by the Parties to the Appeal: A.R.S. 12-904(B)(2)
4 10/9/2012 Exhibits USGS Open-File Report, Evaluation of Simulations Appellant - Patricia Gerrodette
5 11/21/2012 Exhibits USGS STUDY QUANTIFYING PDS� WATER TAKEN FROM BLM Appellant - ROBIN SILVER, M.D.
6 11/30/2012 Exhibits Notice of Filing Supplemental Exhibit Applicant - William Sullivan
7 10/22/2012 List of Witnesses and Exhibits ADWRs' Initial List of Witnesses Agency - Sharon Scantlebury
8 10/22/2012 List of Witnesses and Exhibits ADWRs' Initial List of Exhibits Agency - Sharon Scantlebury
9 10/22/2012 List of Witnesses and Exhibits Bureau of Land Management's Lists of Witnesses and Exhibits Appellant - John Gaudio
10 10/29/2012 List of Witnesses and Exhibits BLM's First Amended List of Exhibits Appellant - John Gaudio
11 11/21/2012 List of Witnesses and Exhibits BLM's First Amended List of Witnesses Appellant - John Gaudio
12 10/22/2012 List of Witnesses and Exhibits List of Witnesses Appellant - Patricia Gerrodette
13 10/22/2012 List of Witnesses and Exhibits List of Exhibits Appellant - Patricia Gerrodette
14 10/25/2012 List of Witnesses and Exhibits Patricia Gerrodette's First Amended List of Exhibits Appellant - Patricia Gerrodette
15 10/22/2012 List of Witnesses and Exhibits EXHIBIT LISTS FOR ROBIN SILVER MD Appellant - ROBIN SILVER MD
16 10/22/2012 List of Witnesses and Exhibits WITNESS LIST FOR ROBIN SILVER MD Appellant - ROBIN SILVER MD
17 10/22/2012 List of Witnesses and Exhibits List of Witnesses and Exhibits Applicant - William P. Sullivan
18 10/23/2012 List of Witnesses and Exhibits PDS Amended List of Witnesses and Exhibits Applicant - William Sullivan
19 12/7/2012 Misc. Motion (specified in description) Joint Motion to Vacate and Reset Deadlines Agency - Sharon Scantlebury
20 12/11/2012 Misc. Motion (specified in description) BLM's Motion to Reconsider Admitting Exhibit RS-23 Into Evid Appellant - John Gaudio
21 10/9/2012 Misc. Motion (specified in description) MOTION TO COMPLETE RECORD Appellant - ROBIN SILVER
22 2/8/2013 Misc. Motion (specified in description) FINAL MOTION Appellant - ROBIN SILVER
23 5/28/2013 Misc. Motion (specified in description) Notice of Filing Complaint for Judicial Review of Adm. Dec. Appellant - Robin Silver
24 11/21/2012 Misc. Motion (specified in description) MOTION TO INCLUDE STUDY QUANTIFYING PDS TAKING OF BLM WATER Appellant - ROBIN SILVER, M.D.
25 11/21/2012 Misc. Motion (specified in description) MOTION TO AMEND EXHIBIT LIST Appellant - ROBIN SILVER, M.D.
26 11/21/2012 Misc. Motion (specified in description) COMPLETE MOTION TO AMENDED EXHIBIT LIST Appellant - ROBIN SILVER, M.D.
27 11/5/2012 Misc. Motion (specified in description) Pueblo del Sol Motion to Dismiss Applicant - William Sullivan
28 11/5/2012 Misc. Motion (specified in description) Pueblo del Sol Request for Witness Summary Applicant - William Sullivan
29 9/21/2012 Misc. Motion (specified in description) Stipulated Motion Re: Hearing Date and Filing Deadlines John Gaudio- Appellant
30 5/28/2013 Misc. Notice Gerrodette Notice of Action Appellant - Patricia Gerrodette
31 1/25/2013 Misc. Notice Joint Notice and Stipulation Regarding Hearing Transcript Applicant - William Sullivan
32 1/30/2013 Misc. Notice Notice of Filing Spreadsheet and Corrections to Exhibit List Applicant - William Sullivan
33 11/5/2012 Motion to Vacate Gerrodette's Motion to Vacate Hearing Appellant - Patricia Gerrodette
34 11/5/2012 Motions in Limine Pueblo del Sol Motion in Limine Applicant - William Sullivan
35 11/21/2012 Notice of Appearance Gerrodette's Notice of Limited Representation Appellant - Patricia Gerrodette
36 10/29/2012 Notice of Pre-Submission of Exhibits (CD with index live links to documents) ADWR's Notice of Filing Exhibits Agency - Sharon Scantlebury
37 10/29/2012 Notice of Pre-Submission of Exhibits (CD with index live links to documents) BLM's Notice of Filing Exhibits Appellant - John Gaudio
38 10/29/2012 Notice of Pre-Submission of Exhibits (CD with index live links to documents) Pueblo del Sol's Notice of Filing Exhibits Applicant - William Sullivan
39 2/8/2013 Post-Hearing Memorandum DWR's Post-Hearing Memorandum Agency - Janet L. Ronald
40 2/8/2013 Post-Hearing Memorandum BLM's Post-Hearing Brief Appellant - John Gaudio
41 2/8/2013 Post-Hearing Memorandum Appellant Patricia Gerrodette's Post-Hearing Closing Brief Appellant - Patricia Gerrodette
42 2/8/2013 Post-Hearing Memorandum PDS Post Hearing Brief Applicant - William Sullivan
43 11/5/2012 Pre-Hearing Memorandum ADWRs' Pre-Hearing Memorandum Agency - Sharon Scantlebury
44 10/23/2012 Pre-Hearing Memorandum question about paper copies of exhibits Appellant - Patricia Gerrodette
45 10/10/2012 Response to Misc. Motion (specified in description) ADWR's Response to Motion to Complete Administrative Record Agency - Sharon Scantlebury
46 12/14/2012 Response to Misc. Motion (specified in description) DWR Response in Opposition to BLMs Motion to Reconsider Admi Agency - Sharon Scantlebury
47 11/14/2012 Response to Misc. Motion (specified in description) BLM's Consolidated Response to Motion to Dismiss Appeals, Mo Appellant - John Gaudio
48 11/14/2012 Response to Misc. Motion (specified in description) Response to Motion PG Nov.14 Appellant - Patricia Gerrodette
49 11/15/2012 Response to Misc. Motion (specified in description) Motion Opposing PDS' Motion to Dismiss/Witness INFO Appellant - ROBIN SILVER, M.D.
50 11/15/2012 Response to Misc. Motion (specified in description) MOTION TO CORRECT ADDITIONAL WITNESS INFO Appellant - ROBIN SILVER, M.D.
51 12/17/2012 Response to Misc. Motion (specified in description) PDS Response in Opposition to BLM's Motion to Reconsider Adm Applicant - William Sullivan
52 11/14/2012 Response to Motion to Vacate ADWR's Response to Gerrodette's Motion to Vacate Hearing Agency - Sharon Scantlebury
53 11/14/2012 Response to Motion to Vacate Pueblo del Sol Response to Motion to Vacate Hearing Applicant - William Sullivan
D.  Exhibits Admitted as Evidence at the Administrative Hearing: A.R.S. 12-904(B)(3); Exhibits Offered, but not Admitted or Withdrawn
54 10/29/2012 Posting of Combined Exhibits Combined Exhibit List Webmaster - Webmaster
E.  Administrative Law Judge Decision and any Revisions or Modifications: A.R.S. 12-904(B)(4)
55 3/13/2013 ALJ Recommended Decision ALJ Recommended Decision Webmaster - Webmaster
56 4/18/2013 Final Agency Action Final Agency Action Webmaster - Webmaster
F.  Transcript: A.R.S. 12-904(B)(5)
57 2/11/2013 Transcript Transcript November 26, 2012 Vol.1 Webmaster
58 2/11/2013 Transcript Transcript November 27, 2012 Vol.2 Webmaster
59 2/11/2013 Transcript Transcript November 28, 2012 Vol.3 Webmaster
60 2/11/2013 Transcript Transcript November 29, 2012 Vol.4 Webmaster
61 2/11/2013 Transcript Transcript November 30, 2012 Vol.5 Webmaster