State of Arizona Office of Administrative Hearings

Electronic Case File

12-002-WQAB
Pima County Flood Control District


Filing Date Document Type Description Filed By
6/11/2012 Posted to Website 6/15/2012 by WebmasterAgency RecordAgency Record 12-002-WQAB Submitted ADEQ June 11,2012Webmaster - Webmaster
6/11/2012 Posted to Website 6/15/2012 by WebmasterAgency RecordAgency Record 12-003-WQAB Submitted ADEQ June 11,2012Webmaster - Webmaster
6/11/2012 Posted to Website 6/15/2012 by WebmasterAgency RecordAgency Record 12-004-WQAB sumbitted ADEQ June 11,2012Webmaster - Webmaster
6/14/2012 Posted to Website 6/15/2012 by WebmasterNotice of HearingNotice of Hearing submitted ADEQ on June 14,2012Webmaster - Webmaster
6/15/2012Pre-Hearing OrderCASE MANAGEMENT ORDER No. 1Administrative Law Judge - Thomas Shedden
6/18/2012Misc. NoticeAmended Notice of AppealIntervenor - Scott Deeny
6/18/2012Misc. Motion (specified in description)Motion to Dismiss (Center for Biological Diversity)Intervenor - Norman D. James
6/18/2012Misc. Motion (specified in description)Motion to Dismiss (Arizona Mining Reform Coalition)Intervenor - Norman D. James
6/18/2012Misc. Motion (specified in description)Motion to Dismiss (Sky Island Alliance)Intervenor - Norman D. James
6/18/2012Misc. Motion (specified in description)Motion to Dismiss (Coalition for Sonoran Desert Protection)Intervenor - Norman D. James
6/18/2012Misc. Motion (specified in description)Motion to Dismiss (Sonoran Institute)Intervenor - Norman D. James
6/18/2012Misc. Motion (specified in description)Motion to Dismiss (Save the Scenic Santa Ritas)Intervenor - Norman D. James
6/18/2012Misc. Motion (specified in description)Motion to Dismiss (Pepper)Intervenor - Norman D. James
6/18/2012Misc. Motion (specified in description)Motion to Dismiss (Elizabeth Murfee DeConcini)Intervenor - Norman D. James
6/18/2012Misc. Motion (specified in description)Motion to Dismiss Appeal (Steele)Intervenor - Norman D. James
6/18/2012Misc. Motion (specified in description)Motion to Dismiss Appeal (Hart)Intervenor - Norman D. James
6/18/2012Misc. Motion (specified in description)Motion to Dismiss Appeal (Purdon)Intervenor - Norman D. James
6/18/2012Misc. Motion (specified in description)Motion to Dismiss Appeal (Dino DeConcini)Intervenor - Norman D. James
6/18/2012Misc. Motion (specified in description)Motion to Dismiss Appeal (Urken)Intervenor - Norman D. James
6/18/2012Misc. Motion (specified in description)Motion to Dismiss Appeal (Sierra Club GC Chapter)Intervenor - Norman D. James
6/18/2012Misc. Motion (specified in description)Motion to Dismiss Appeal (Walden)Intervenor - Norman D. James
6/18/2012Misc. Motion (specified in description)Motion to Dismiss Appeal (Kozma)Intervenor - Norman D. James
6/19/2012Misc. Motion (specified in description)Letter to Arizona Dept of AdministrationAppellant (changed from Intervenor by Webmaster 7/2/2012) - Scott Deeny
6/20/2012Motion for Pre-Hearing ConferenceMotion for Pre-hearing ConferenceAppellant (changed from Intervenor by Webmaster 7/2/2012) - Scott Deeny
6/20/2012Motion to ContinueMotion to Continue HearingAppellant (changed from Intervenor by Webmaster 7/2/2012) - Scott Deeny
6/22/2012Misc. Motion (specified in description)Joint Response to MO to Continue Hearing/MO for Prehrg ConfIntervenor - Norman D. James
6/25/2012 (1 duplicate removed 6/26/2012 - Webmaster)Misc. Motion (specified in description)Amended JoinerAppellant (changed from Intervenor by Webmaster 7/2/2012) - Thomas F. Purdon
6/25/2012 (1duplicate removed 6/26/2012 - Webmaster)Response to Misc. Motion (specified in description)Response to Motion to DismissAppellant - Sky Island Alliance
6/25/2012Response to Misc. Motion (specified in description)Amended JoinderAppellant - Sky Island Alliance
6/25/2012Misc. Motion (specified in description)Response to Motion to DismissAppellant - Thomas F. Purdon
6/25/2012 (2 duplicates removed 6/25/2012 - Webmaster)Misc. Motion (specified in description)Response to Motion to DismissAppellant - Arnold B. Urken
6/25/2012Misc. Motion (specified in description)Amended JoinerAppellant - Arnold B. Urken
6/25/2012Misc. Motion (specified in description)Response to Motion to DismissAppellant - Carolyn Campbell
6/25/2012Misc. Motion (specified in description)Amended JoinderAppellant - Carolyn Campbell
6/25/2012 (8 duplicates removed 6/25/2012 - Webmaster)Misc. NoticeAmended Joinder in Notice of AppealAppellant (changed from Intervenor by Webmaster 7/2/2012) - Scott Deeny
6/25/2012Misc. Motion (specified in description)Response to Motion to DismissAppellant - Arizona Mining Reform Coalition
6/25/2012Misc. Motion (specified in description)Response to Rosemont CopperAppellant (changed from Intervenor by Webmaster 7/2/2012) - Scott Deeny
6/25/2012Misc. Motion (specified in description)Amended JoinderAppellant - Arizona Mining Reform Coalition
6/25/2012ExhibitsExhibit GS-1 Response to Rosemont Copper MotionAppellant (changed from Intervenor by Webmaster 7/2/2012) - Scott Deeny
6/25/2012ExhibitsExhibit GS-2 Response to Rosemont Copper MotionAppellant (changed from Intervenor by Webmaster 7/2/2012) - Scott Deeny
6/25/2012ExhibitsExhibit GS-3 Response to Rosemont Copper MotionAppellant (changed from Intervenor by Webmaster 7/2/2012) - Scott Deeny
6/25/2012ExhibitsExhibit GS-4 Response to Rosemont Copper MotionAppellant (changed from Intervenor by Webmaster 7/2/2012) - Scott Deeny
6/25/2012ExhibitsExhibit GS-5 Response to Rosemont Copper MotionAppellant (changed from Intervenor by Webmaster 7/2/2012) - Scott Deeny
6/25/2012Misc. Motion (specified in description)Response to Motion to DismissAppellant - James E. and Sherry M. Pepper
6/25/2012Response to Misc. Motion (specified in description)Amended JoinderAppellant - James E. and Sherry M. Pepper
6/25/2012Misc. Motion (specified in description)Response To Motion To DismissAppellant - John M. Kozma
6/25/2012 (1 duplicate removed 6/25/2012 - Webmaster)Misc. Motion (specified in description)Response to Motion to DismissAppellant - Stanley R. Hart
6/25/2012 (1 duplicate removed 6/25/2012 - Webmaster)Misc. Motion (specified in description)Amended JoinderAppellant - Stanley R. Hart
6/25/2012Misc. Motion (specified in description)Amended JoinderAppellant - John M. Kozma
6/25/2012Misc. Motion (specified in description)Sierra Club Response to Rosemont Motion to DismissAppellant - Steven Pawlowski
6/25/2012Misc. Motion (specified in description)Response to Motion to DismissAppellant - Lisa Froelich
6/25/2012Misc. Motion (specified in description)Amended JoinderAppellant - Lisa Froelich
6/25/2012Misc. Motion (specified in description)Response to Motion to DismissAppellant - David S. Steele
6/25/2012Misc. Motion (specified in description)Amended JoinderAppellant - David S. Steele
6/25/2012Misc. Motion (specified in description)Response to Motion to Dismiss Appellant - Center for Biological Diversity
6/25/2012Misc. Motion (specified in description)Amended JoinderAppellant - Center for Biological Diversity
6/25/2012Misc. Motion (specified in description)Amended Joinder MotionAppellant - Steve Pawlowski
6/27/2012 - posted by Webmaster 6/28/2012; received through OAH e-mail 6/27/2012Response to Motion for Pre-Hearing ConferenceADEQ Response to Motion for Prehearing ConferenceRespondent - Leslie Kyman Cooper
6/28/2012Motion to ContinueMotion to Continue HearingAppellant - Harlan Agnew
6/28/2012Misc. Motion (specified in description)Reply in Support of Motion to Dismiss Appeal (Pepper)Intervenor - Norman D. James
6/28/2012Misc. Motion (specified in description)Reply in Support of Motion to Dismiss Appeal (Steele)Intervenor - Norman D. James
6/28/2012Misc. Motion (specified in description)Reply in Support of Motion to Dismiss Appeal (Urken)Intervenor - Norman D. James
6/28/2012Misc. Motion (specified in description)Reply in Support of Motion to Dismiss Appeal (Hart)Intervenor - Norman D. James
6/28/2012Misc. Motion (specified in description)Reply in Support of Motion to Dismiss Appeal (Kozma)Intervenor - Norman D. James
6/28/2012Misc. Motion (specified in description)Reply in Support of Motion to Dismiss Appeal (Purdon)Intervenor - Norman D. James
6/28/2012Misc. Motion (specified in description)Reply in Support of MO to Dismiss Joinder In Appeal (Walden)Intervenor - Norman D. James
6/28/2012Misc. Motion (specified in description)Reply in Support of MO to Dismiss Appeal (Ctr for Biol Div)Intervenor - Norman D. James
6/28/2012Misc. Motion (specified in description)Reply in Support of MO to Dismiss Appeal (Sierra Club-GCC)Intervenor - Norman D. James
6/28/2012Misc. Motion (specified in description)Reply in Support of MO to Dismiss Appeal (Sky Island Allian)Intervenor - Norman D. James
6/28/2012Misc. Motion (specified in description)Reply in Support of MO to Dismiss Appeal (AZ Mining Reform)Intervenor - Norman D. James
6/28/2012Misc. Motion (specified in description)Reply in Support of MO to Dismiss Appeal (Coal Sonoran Dese)Intervenor - Norman D. James
6/28/2012Misc. Motion (specified in description)Reply in Support of MO to Dismiss Appeal (SSSR)Intervenor - Norman D. James
6/29/2012Misc. Motion (specified in description)Motion to Strike Appellants' Amended Notices of AppealIntervenor - Norman D. James
6/29/2012 (posted by Webmaster on behalf of Leslie Cooper)Administrative RecordAdministrative RecordWebmaster
6/29/2012Pre-Hearing OrderCASE MANAGEMENT ORDER No. 2Administrative Law Judge - Thomas Shedden
7/2/2012Misc. NoticeNotice of Withdrawal of Snall & WilmerAppellant - Scott Deeny
7/2/2012Misc. NoticeNotice of Making Record Available to OAH WebsiteRespondent - Leslie Kyman Cooper
7/2/2012Misc. Motion (specified in description)Motion to Dismiss Appeal (Shinsky)Intervenor - Norman D. James
7/2/2012Misc. NoticeDeclaration of Grady M. O�BrienIntervenor - Norman D. James
7/2/2012Misc. Motion (specified in description)Motion to Dismiss Issues Raised in Shinsky AppealIntervenor - Norman D. James
7/2/2012Misc. NoticeTechnical Changes by WebmasterWebmaster - Webmaster
7/3/2012Pre-Hearing OrderCASE MANAGEMENT ORDER No. 3Administrative Law Judge - Thomas Shedden
7/11/2012Response to Misc. Motion (specified in description)Appellants Response to Rosemont's Motion to StrikeApplicant - Scott Deeny
7/11/2012Response to Misc. Motion (specified in description)Shinskys Response to Rosemont's Motion to Dismiss AppealApplicant - Scott Deeny
7/13/2012Misc. NoticeResponse to Case Management Order #3Appellant - Josef E. Marlow / Sonoran Institute
7/13/2012Misc. NoticeList of Issues for Discussion at Pre-Hearing ConferenceAppellant - Harlan Agnew
7/13/2012Misc. NoticeShinskys' and Waldens' List of Issues for pre-hearing conf.Appellant - Scott Deeny
7/13/2012Misc. Motion (specified in description)Rosemont's Reply in Support of MTD Appeal of ShinskyIntervenor - Norman D. James
7/13/2012Misc. NoticeRosemont's List of Issues for Prehearing ConferenceIntervenor - Norman D. James
7/13/2012Misc. Motion (specified in description)Reply in Support MTS Appellants' Amend. Notices of AppealIntervenor - Norman D. James
7/13/2012Misc. NoticeADEQ's List of Issues for Pre-Heaing ConferenceRespondent - JE Barraza
7/16/2012Misc. Motion (specified in description)Sky Island_Response to Case Man. Order #3: Statement of OrgAppellant - Sky Island Alliance
7/16/2012Misc. NoticeRosemont's Stmt of Issues Raised in Appllnts� Ntcs of AppealIntervenor - Norman D. James
7/16/2012Misc. Motion (specified in description)Organizational StatementAppellant - John Buse
7/16/2012Misc. Motion (specified in description)SSSR_Response to Case Man. Order #3- Statement of OrgAppellant - Lisa Froelich
7/16/2012Misc. Motion (specified in description)Response to Case Man. Order #3- Organizational StatementAppellant - Arizona Mining Reform Coalition
7/16/2012Misc. Motion (specified in description)Sierra Club's Response to Case Management Order #3 Appellant - Steve Pawlowski
7/16/2012Misc. Motion (specified in description)Shinsky and Waldens' Statement of Factual and Legal IssuesAppellant - Scott Deeny
7/16/2012Misc. NoticeStatement of Factual and Legal IssuesAppellant - Harlan Agnew
7/17/2012Pre-Hearing OrderCASE MANAGEMENT ORDER No. 4Administrative Law Judge - Thomas Shedden
7/19/2012Motion to ContinuePima County's Motion to Continue & Motion to Postpone DeadliAppellant - Harlan Agnew
7/19/2012Response to Motion to ContinueShinsky and Waldens Joinder in Response to Pima County's Appellant - Scott Deeny
7/19/2012Misc. NoticeADEQ's Notice of Substituion of CounselRespondent - Jennie E Barraza
7/19/2012Denying Misc. MotionCASE MANAGEMENT ORDER No. 5Administrative Law Judge - Thomas Shedden
7/23/2012Response to Misc. Motion (specified in description)Sky Island Alliance_Rule 31 Statement of Org_REFILINGAppellant - Sky Island Alliance
7/23/2012Misc. Motion (specified in description)Rosemont's Renewed Motion to Dismiss Barchas AppealIntervenor - Norman D. James
7/23/2012Pre-Hearing OrderCASE MANAGEMENT ORDER No. 6Administrative Law Judge - Thomas Shedden
7/24/2012Notice of AppearancePima County Notice of Appearance of Regina NassenAppellant - Regina Nassen
7/24/2012Response to Motion to ContinueRosemont's Response to Pima Cnty's Mot. to Continue HearingIntervenor - Norman D. James
7/24/2012Misc. Motion (specified in description)CSDP Statement of Organization - Response to CMO 3 & 4Appellant - Coalition for Sonoran Desert Protection
7/24/2012Misc. Motion (specified in description)CSDP Statement of Issues - Response to CMO 3 & 4Appellant - Coalition for Sonoran Desert Protection
7/24/2012Response to Misc. Motion (specified in description)Shinsky Response to Rosemont's Motion to Dismiss IssuesAppellant - G. Van Velsor Wolf Jr.
7/24/2012Misc. Motion (specified in description)Shinskys and Waldens Amended Statement of Factual and Legal Appellant - Scott Deeny
7/24/2012Misc. NoticePima County's Supplemental Statement of Factual & Legal IssuAppellant - Harlan Agnew
7/24/2012Response to Misc. Motion (specified in description)Pima County's Reply to Rosemont's Response to Motion to ContAppellant - Harlan Agnew
7/24/2012Misc. Motion (specified in description)Sierra Club Joinder in Shinsky Issue Statement Appellant - Steve Pawlowski
7/25/2012Audio RecordHearing Audio July 20, 2012

Webmaster
7/25/2012Technical BulletinWebmaster's Advisement-Technical Bulletin 2Webmaster - Webmaster
7/25/2012Denying Motion to ContinueCASE MANAGEMENT ORDER No. 7Administrative Law Judge - Thomas Shedden
7/26/2012Misc. Motion (specified in description)Rosemont�s Rply Sup MTD Issues Raisd In Shinskys Ntc AppealIntervenor - Norman D. James
7/26/2012Misc. Motion (specified in description)Rosemont�s Rply Sup MTD Issues Raisd In Shinskys Ntc AppealIntervenor - Norman D. James
7/27/2012Misc. Motion (specified in description)Shinskys and Waldens Motion for Reconsideration of CMO #7Appellant - G. Van Velsor Wolf Jr.
7/27/2012Misc. Motion (specified in description)Statement of Organization or Identity, etc.Appellant - Sarah Barchas
7/27/2012Misc. Motion (specified in description)Request for Clarification of CMO 7 Relative to Discl. StmtsAppellant - Scott Deeny
7/30/2012Notice of AppearanceCBD&Sierra Club Notice of Appearance/Substitution of CounselAppellant - Angela R. Trujillo
7/30/2012Minute EntryMinute Entry No. 1Administrative Law Judge - Thomas Shedden
7/30/2012Misc. NoticeSierra Club's Notice of Withdrawal of CounselAppellant - Lawrence V. Robertson, Jr
7/30/2012Misc. Motion (specified in description)CBD's Motion for Extension for Filing Disclosure StatementAppellant - Lawrence V. Robertson, Jr.
7/30/2012Misc. Motion (specified in description)The Center's Request for Further Clarification of CMO 7Appellant - Lawrence V. Robertson, Jr.
7/31/2012Misc. Motion (specified in description)Sierra Club Notice of Withdrawal Appellant - Steve Pawlowski
7/31/2012Misc. Motion (specified in description)Rosemont's Rply in Supp of Rnwd MO to Dismiss Barchas AppealIntervenor - Norman D. James
7/31/2012Minute EntryMinute Entry No. 2Administrative Law Judge - Thomas Shedden
7/31/2012Misc. Motion (specified in description)Shinsky and Waldens Motion to Adopt New Naming Convention Appellant - G. Van Velsor Wolf Jr.
7/31/2012Misc. Motion (specified in description)Motion to WithdrawInterested Party - Jimmy and Sherry Pepper
7/31/2012Misc. Motion (specified in description)Sonoran Institute Notice of WithdrawalAppellant - Josef E. Marlow / Sonoran Institute
8/1/2012Misc. Motion (specified in description)The Center's Continued Request for Extension of Time Interested Party - Lawrence V. Robertson, Jr.
8/1/2012Response to Misc. Motion (specified in description)Rosemont's Resp to Shinskys & Waldens MO for ReconsiderationIntervenor - Norman D. James
8/1/2012Response to Misc. Motion (specified in description)Rosemont Resp to CBD MO for Ext of DisclosuresIntervenor - Norman D. James
8/1/2012Pre-Hearing OrderCASE MANAGEMENT ORDER No. 8Administrative Law Judge - Thomas Shedden
8/1/2012Pre-Hearing MemorandumPima County and PCFCD's Prehearing Disclosure StatementAppellant - Regina Nassen
8/1/2012Pre-Hearing MemorandumThe Center's Disclosure StatementInterested Party - Lawrence V. Robertson, Jr.
8/2/2012Pre-Hearing MemorandumRosemont Prehearing Disclosure StatementIntervenor - Norman D. James
8/2/2012Pre-Hearing MemorandumThe Shinsky Appellants' A.A.C. R2-17-110 Prehearing Discl.Appellant - Scott Deeny
8/2/2012Misc. NoticeADEQ's First Disclosure StatementRespondent - Jennie E. Barraza
8/3/2012Response to Misc. Motion (specified in description)Shinsky Appellants Reply to Rosemont's Response to Shinskys'Appellant - Scott Deeny
8/3/2012Misc. NoticePima County and PCFCD's Witness Availability per CMO 6Appellant - Regina Nassen
8/3/2012Minute EntryMinute Entry No. 3Administrative Law Judge - Thomas Shedden
8/3/2012Pre-Hearing OrderCASE MANAGEMENT ORDER No. 9Administrative Law Judge - Thomas Shedden
8/6/2012Misc. Motion (specified in description)NO of Stipulation Concerning Filing & Service of DocumentsIntervenor - Norman D. James
8/6/2012ExhibitsThe Center's Confirmation of Position as to Filing ExhibitsInterested Party - Lawrence V. Robertson, Jr.
8/6/2012ExhibitsRosemont NO of Filing Exh Disclosed in PreHrg DisclIntervenor - Norman D. James
8/6/2012ExhibitsShinsky Appellants' Index of Documents and Exhibits and DVDAppellant - Scott Deeny
8/6/2012Misc. NoticeADEQ's Notice of Filing Exhibits and Index of ExhibitsRespondent - Jennie E. Barraza
8/6/2012Misc. Motion (specified in description)Rosemont Submission of Witness Availability per CMO6Intervenor - Norman D. James
8/6/2012ExhibitsShinsky Appellants' Notice of Clarification of Exhibits Appellant - Scott Deeny
8/6/2012Misc. NoticeThe Center's Witness and Counsel Availability Per CMO 6Interested Party - Lawrence V. Robertson, Jr.
8/6/2012Misc. Motion (specified in description)Shinsky Appellants Submission of Witness AvailabilityAppellant - Scott Deeny
8/7/2012Misc. NoticeADEQ's Notice of Availability for Additional Hearing Dates Respondent - Jennie E. Barraza
8/7/2012Misc. NoticePima County & PRFCD's Notice of Filing ExhibitsAppellant - Regina Nassen
8/7/2012,Index updated by Webmaster 8/22/2012 to reflect receipt of corrected exhibit; ; Index updated by Webmaster 8/24/2012 to reflect receipt of exhibitElectronic Posting of ExhibitsADEQ ExhibitsWebmaster
8/7/2012Electronic Posting of ExhibitsTD>Pima County & PRFCD's ExhibitsWebmaster
8/7/2012,Index updated by Webmaster 8/9/2012 to reflect receipt of exhibits, Index updated by Webmaster 8/10/2012 to reflect receipt of exhibits; Index updated by Webmaster 8/21/2012 to reflect receipt of exhibits; Index updated by Webmaster 8/22/2012 to reflect receipt of exhibits; Index updated by Webmaster 9/7/2012 to reflect receipt of exhibits;Index updated by Webmaster 9/14/2012 to reflect receipt of exhibits;Index updated by Webmaster 9/24/2012 to reflect receipt of exhibits;Electronic Posting of ExhibitsRosemont Copper Company's ExhibitsWebmaster
8/7/2012,Index updated by Webmaster 8/8/2012 to reflect receipt of exhibits; Index updated by Webmaster 8/9/2012 to reflect receipt of exhibits; Index updated by Webmaster 8/24/2012 to reflect receipt of exhibits; Index updated by Webmaster 8/28/2012 to reflect receipt of exhibits;Index updated by Webmaster 9/14/2012 to reflect receipt of exhibits;Index updated by Webmaster 10/12/2012 to reflect receipt of corrected exhibit; Electronic Posting of ExhibitsShinsky ExhibitsWebmaster
8/7/2012Misc. NoticeNotice of Posting of ExhibitsWebmaster - Webmaster
8/7/2012Misc. Motion (specified in description)Stipulation and Motion to Extend Deadlines for Prehearing MeRespondent - Jennie E. Barraza
8/7/2012ExhibitsShinsky Appellants Supp Documents and DVDAppellant - Scott Deeny
8/8/2012Misc. NoticeWebmaster AdvisementWebmaster - Webmaster
8/8/2012ExhibitsShinsky Appellants 2nd Supp Docs and DVDAppellant - Scott Deeny
8/8/2012Misc. Motion (specified in description)The Center's MO to Late File Stmnt of Legal & Factual IssuesInterested Party - Lawrence V. Robertson, Jr.
8/8/2012ExhibitsShinsky Appellants Index of Rebuttal Docs and Ex and DVDAppellant - Scott Deeny
8/8/2012Misc. Motion (specified in description)Rosemont's Rebuttal Disclosure StatementIntervenor - Norman D. James
8/8/2012ExhibitsRosemont NO of Filing Rebuttal Exh Disclsd in Reb DSIntervenor - Norman D. James
8/8/2012Pre-Hearing OrderCASE MANAGEMENT ORDER No. 10Administrative Law Judge - Thomas Shedden
8/9/2012Misc. NoticeElectronic Posting of ExhibitsWebmaster - webmaster
8/9/2012Misc. Motion (specified in description)Rosemont NO of Withdrawal of ExhibitsIntervenor - Norman D. James
8/9/2012ExhibitsRosemont NO of Filing Supp Exh Discld in Supp DSIntervenor - Norman D. James
8/10/2012,Index updated by Webmaster 8/21/2012 to reflect receipt of exhibits; Index updated by Webmaster 8/22/2012 to reflect receipt of exhibitsElectronic Posting of ExhibitsMisc. NoticeElectronic Posting of ExhibitsWebmaster - Webmaster
8/13/2012Misc. NoticePima County Notice of Settlement & Intent to Withdraw AppealAppellant - Harlan Agnew
8/13/2012Motions in LimineRosemont MO re NEPA & MIL re FellerIntervenor - Norman D. James
8/13/2012Motions in LimineRosemont MIL re OsterkampIntervenor - Norman D. James
8/13/2012Motions in LimineRosemont MIL re SerraglioIntervenor - Norman D. James
8/13/2012Pre-Hearing MemorandumRosemont's Prehearing MemorandumIntervenor - Norman D. James
8/13/2012Pre-Hearing MemorandumThe Center's Pre-Hearing Memorandum Interested Party - Lawrence V. Robertson, Jr.
8/13/2012Motions in LimineADEQ's Mot In Limine to Exclude Expert Testimony of Joseph MRespondent - Jennie E Barraza
8/13/2012Response to Motions in LimineADEQ's Mot lin Limine to Exclude Evidence Regarding the LackRespondent - Jennie E Barraza
8/13/2012Response to Motions in LimineADEQ's Mot in Limine to Exclude Expert Testimony of Dr. ArnoRespondent - Jennie E Barraza
8/13/2012Misc. Motion (specified in description)Shinsky Appellants Motion in Limine to Preclude ExpertAppellant - Scott Deeny
8/13/2012Pre-Hearing MemorandumThe Shinsky Appellants Prehearing MemorandumAppellant - Scott Deeny
8/13/2012Motions in LimineRosemont's Joinder in Motions in Limine filed by ADEQIntervenor - Norman D. James
8/13/2012Pre-Hearing MemorandumADEQ's Prehearing MemorandumRespondent - Jennie E Barraza
8/17/2012, Index updated by Webmaster 8/21/2012 to reflect receipt of exhibits; Index updated by Webmaster 8/22/2012 to reflect receipt of exhibits; Index updated by Webmaster 8/24/2012 to reflect receipt of exhibits; Index updated by Webmaster 8/28/2012 to reflect receipt of exhibits; Index updated by Webmaster 8/30/2012 to reflect receipt of exhibits; Index updated by Webmaster 9/7/2012 to reflect receipt of exhibits; Index updated by Webmaster 9/14/2012 to reflect receipt of exhibits: Index updated by Webmaster 9/19/2012 to reflect receipt of exhibits; Index updated by Webmaster 9/24/2012 to reflect receipt of exhibits; Index updated by Webmaster 10/12/2012 to reflect receipt of corrected exhibit; updated by Webmaster 10/12/2012 to reflect status of exhibitsElectronic Posting of Exhibits Electronic Posting of Combined Exhibit ListCombined Exhibit ListWebmaster
8/17/2012Misc. NoticeWebmaster Advisement of Posting of Combined Exhibit ListWebmaster - Webmaster
8/17/2012Pre-Hearing OrderCASE MANAGEMENT ORDER No. 11Administrative Law Judge - Thomas Shedden
8/17/2012Response to Motions in LimineThe Center's Rspnse to Rosemont's MO in Limine Re SerraglioInterested Party - Lawrence V. Robertson, Jr.
8/20/2012Response to Motions in LimineShinsky Appellants' Response to Rosemonts MIL re OsterkampAppellant - Scott Deeny
8/20/2012Response to Motions in LimineShinsky Appellants Response to ADEQs MIL re LinersAppellant - Scott Deeny
8/20/2012Response to Motions in LimineShinsky Appellants' Response to MIL re Feller and NEPA issueAppellant - Scott Deeny
8/20/2012Response to Motions in LimineShinsky Appellants Response to ADEQs MIL re UrkenAppellant - Scott Deeny
8/20/2012Reply to Response to Motions in LimineRosemont's Reply in Support of MIL to Preclude SerraglioIntervenor - Norman D. James
8/20/2012Response to Motions in LimineADEQ's Response to MIL To Exclude Expert Opinion TestimonyRespondent - Jennie E Barraza
8/20/2012Misc. Motion (specified in description)Rosemont's 1st Supplemental Disclosure StatementIntervenor - Norman D. James
8/20/2012ExhibitsRosemont's NO of Filing Exh Disclsd in 1st Supp Discl StmntIntervenor - Norman D. James
8/20/2012Pre-Hearing OrderCASE MANAGEMENT ORDER No. 12Administrative Law Judge - Thomas Shedden
8/21/2012Reply to Response to Motions in LimineRosemont's Reply in Support of MIL to Exclude UrkenIntervenor - Norman D. James
8/21/2012Reply to Response to Motions in LimineRosemont's Reply in Support of MIL to Preclude OsterkampIntervenor - Norman D. James
8/21/2012Misc. Motion (specified in description)Rosemont's Reply in Support of MSJ re NEPA & MIL re FellerIntervenor - Norman D. James
8/21/2012Misc. Motion (specified in description)Rosemont's 2nd Supplemental Disclosure StatementIntervenor - Norman D. James
8/21/2012ExhibitsRosemont's NO of Filing Exh Disclsd in 2nd Supp Discl StmntIntervenor - Norman D. James
8/21/2012Misc. NoticeADEQ's Notice of Errata And Corrected Exhibit ADEQ-2Respondent - Jennie E Barrazaza
8/21/2012Misc. Motion (specified in description)Shinsky Appellants Motion for Reconsideration of CMO 12 Appellant - Scott Deeny
8/22/2012Misc. NoticeAdvisement of Posting of ADEQ and Rosement Exhibits Webmaster - Webmaster
8/22/2012Misc. Motion (specified in description)Center's Joinder to Shinsky MO for Reconsideration of CMO 12Interested Party - Lawrence V. Robertson, Jr.
8/22/2012Reply to Response to Motions in LimineShinsky Appellants Reply in Support of their MIL to precludeAppellant - Scott Deeny
8/22/2012Misc. Motion (specified in description)Shinsky Appellants 1st Supp. Disclosure StmtAppellant - Scott Deeny
8/22/2012Misc. Motion (specified in description)Shinsky Appellants Notice of Filing Supp ExhibitsAppellant - Scott Deeny
8/22/2012Reply to Response to Motions in LimineADEQ's Reply Joining Rosemont's Reply In Support of MIL FellRespondent - Jennie E Barraza
8/22/2012Misc. NoticeADEQ's Disclosure And Notice of Filing Supplemental ExhibitsRespondent - Jennie E Barraza
8/22/2012Reply to Response to Motions in LimineADEQ's Reply Joining In Rosemont's Reply of MIL UrkenRespondent - Jennie E Barraza
8/22/2012Response to Misc. Motion (specified in description)Rosemont's Response to Shinskys' MO for Recon re Issue 14Intervenor - Norman D. James
8/22/2012Misc. Motion (specified in description)The Center's 1st Supp. Disclosure StmtInterested Party - Larry Robertson
8/22/2012Misc. Motion (specified in description)The Center's Notice of filing exhibits disclosed in 1st SuppInterested Party - Larry Robertson
8/23/2012Misc. Motion (specified in description)Shinsky Appellants Reply in Supp of Motion for Reconsid.Appellant - Scott Deeny
8/24/2012Minute EntryMinute Entry No. 4 Administrative Law Judge - Thomas Shedden
8/24/2012; Index updated by Webmaster 8/30/2012 to reflect receipt of exhibit; Index updated by Webmaster 9/14/2012 to reflect receipt of exhibits;Electronic Posting of ExhibitsCenter for Biological Diversity ExhibitsWebmaster
8/24/2012Misc. NoticeAdvisement of Posting of ADEQ, Shinsky, and CBD ExhibitsWebmaster - Webmaster
8/24/2012Misc. NoticeNotice of Filing Shinsky Appellants' Additional VerificationAppellant - G. Van Velsor Wolf Jr.
8/24/2012Hearing Room Table AssignmentsDiagram of Hearing Room Table AssignmentsWebmasterTD>
8/24/2012Misc. NoticeAdvisement of Posting of Table Assignments, Hearing Room AWebmaster - Webmaster
8/24/2012Pre-Hearing OrderCASE MANAGEMENT ORDER No. 13Administrative Law Judge - Thomas Shedden
8/27/2012Misc. Motion (specified in description)Shinsky Appellants 2nd Supp. Docs and DVDAppellant - Scott Deeny
8/27/2012Misc. Motion (specified in description)Shinsky Appellants Notice of Filing Supp. ExAppellant - Scott Deeny
8/29/2012Misc. NoticeNotice of Posting of Supplemental ExhibitWebmaster - Webmaster
8/29/2012; see also 7/25/2012 technical advisementAudio RecordHearing Audio August 27, 2012

Webmaster
8/29/2012; see also 7/25/2012 technical advisementAudio RecordHearing Audio August 28, 2012

Webmaster
8/30/2012; see also 7/25/2012 technical advisementAudio RecordHearing Audio August 29, 2012

Webmaster
8/30/2012ExhibitsThe Center's Notice of Filing and Filing of Exhibit CBD - 3 Interested Party - Lawrence V. Robertson, Jr.
8/30/2012Misc. NoticePosting of CBD ExhibitWebmaster - Webmaster
8/30/2012Misc. Motion (specified in description)Pima County and PCFCD's Motion for Severance & ReferralAppellant - Harlan Agnew
8/31/2012; see also 7/25/2012 technical advisementAudio RecordHearing Audio August 30, 2012

Webmaster
8/31/2012; see also 7/25/2012 technical advisementAudio RecordHearing Audio August 31, 2012

Webmaster
9/6/2012Misc. Motion (specified in description)Rosemont's 3rd Supplemental Disclosure StatementIntervenor - Norman D. James
9/6/2012Misc. Motion (specified in description)Rosemont's NO of Filing Exh Disclsd in 3rd Supp Discl StmntIntervenor - Norman D. James
9/7/2012Misc. NoticePosting of Rosemont Supplemental ExhibitsWebmaster - Webmaster
9/11/2012TranscriptTranscripts August 27 - August 31, 2012Webmaster - Webmaster
9/12/2012Misc. Motion (specified in description)Shinsky Appellants Third Supplemental Disclosure StatementAppellant - Scott M. Deeny
9/12/2012Misc. NoticeNotice of Filing Third Supplemental ExhibitsAppellant - Scott M. Deeny
9/12/2012Pre-Hearing OrderCASE MANAGEMENT ORDER No. 14Administrative Law Judge - Thomas Shedden
9/12/2012Pre-Hearing OrderCASE MANAGEMENT ORDER No. 15Administrative Law Judge - Thomas Shedden
9/13/2012Misc. Motion (specified in description)Rosemont's 4th Supplemental Disclosure StatementIntervenor - Norman D. James
9/13/2012Misc. Motion (specified in description)Rosemont's NO of Filing Exh Disclsd in 4th Supp Discl StmntIntervenor - Norman D. James
9/13/2012Misc. Motion (specified in description)The Center's Second Supplemental Disclosure StatementInterested Party - Lawrence V. Robertson, Jr.
9/14/2012Misc. Motion (specified in description)Shinsky Appellants Fourth Supplemental Disclosure StatementAppellant - Scott M. Deeny
9/14/2012Misc. NoticeShinsky Appellants Notice of Filing 4th Supp. Disclosure Appellant - Scott M. Deeny
9/14/2012Misc. NoticeNotice of Posting of Supplemental ExhibitsWebmaster - Webmaster
9/14/2012Misc. Motion (specified in description)Rosemont's 5th Supplemental Disclosure StatementIntervenor - Norman D. James
9/14/2012Misc. Motion (specified in description)Rosemont's NO of Filing Exh Disclsd in 5th Supp Discl StmntIntervenor - Norman D. James
9/14/2012Misc. NoticeNotice of Posting of Supplemental ExhibitsWebmaster - Webmaster
9/14/2012Misc. NoticeNotice of Posting of Supplemental ExhibitsWebmaster - Webmaster
9/14/2012Misc. NoticeNotice of Posting of Supplemental ExhibitsWebmaster - Webmaster
9/18/2012; see also 7/25/2012 technical advisementAudio RecordHearing Audio September 17, 2012

Webmaster
9/19/2012; see also 7/25/2012 technical advisementAudio RecordHearing Audio September 18, 2012

Webmaster
9/19/2012ExhibitsThe Center’s Notice of Filing and Filing of Exhibit CBD-12Interested Party - Lawrence V. Robertson, Jr.
9/19/2012Misc. NoticeNotice of Posting of Supplemental ExhibitsWebmaster - Webmaster
9/20/2012; see also 7/25/2012 technical advisementAudio RecordHearing Audio September 19, 2012

Webmaster
9/21/2012; see also 7/25/2012 technical advisementAudio RecordHearing Audio September 20, 2012

Webmaster
9/21/2012Misc. Motion (specified in description)Rosemont's 6th Supplemental Disclosure StatementIntervenor - Norman D. James
9/21/2012Misc. Motion (specified in description)Rosemont's NO of Filing Exh Disclsd in 6th Supp Discl StmntIntervenor - Norman D. James
9/24/2012Misc. NoticePosting of Rosemont Exhibit 151Webmaster - Webmaster
9/24/2012Pre-Hearing OrderCASE MANAGEMENT ORDER No. 16Administrative Law Judge - Thomas Shedden
10/4/2012TranscriptTranscripts September 17 - September 20, 2012Webmaster - Webmaster
10/11/2012Misc. NoticeShinsky Appellants' Notice of Errata and Corrected Ex-49Appellant - G. Van Velsor Wolf Jr.
10/12/2012Misc. NoticeNotice of posting of corrected exhibitWebmaster - Webmaster
10/17/2012Misc. Motion (specified in description)Shinsky Appellants Motion to Allow Post-Hearing Submission Appellant - G. Van Velsor Wolf Jr.
10/18/2012Misc. Motion (specified in description)Center’s Joinder to Shinsky MO to Allow Post-Hrg EvidenceInterested Party - Lawrence V. Robertson, Jr.
10/19/2012Misc. Motion (specified in description)Rosemont's Resp to Shinksy MO to Allow Post-Hrg Sub of EvidIntervenor - Norman D. James
10/22/2012Misc. Motion (specified in description)Shinsky Appellants' Reply to Rosemont's Response to MotionAppellant - G. Van Velsor Wolf Jr.
10/22/2012Misc. Motion (specified in description)Center’s Joinder to SAs Reply to Rosemont’s Resp to SAs MOInterested Party - Lawrence V. Robertson, Jr.
10/23/2012Misc. Motion (specified in description)Offer of Proof: Affidavit of Dr. Feller re Issue #4Appellant - G. Van Velsor Wolf Jr.
10/25/2012Misc. Motion (specified in description)Rosemont's Objection to Shinsky's Offer of ProofIntervenor - Norman D. James
10/25/2012Post-Hearing OrderCASE MANAGEMENT ORDER No. 17Administrative Law Judge - Thomas Shedden
10/29/2012Post-Hearing MemorandumThe Center's Post-Hearing Legal Memorandum Interested Party - Lawrence V. Robertson, Jr.
10/29/2012Post-Hearing MemorandumShinsky Appellants' Post-Hearing Legal MemorandumAppellant - G.
10/29/2012Proposed Findings of Fact and Conclusions of LawShinsky Appellants' Proposed Findings of Fact and ConclusionAppellant - G. Van Velsor Wolf Jr.
11/1/2012Response to Misc. Motion (specified in description)Shinsky Appellants Response to Rosemonts Objection & MO StriAppellant - G. Van Velsor Wolf Jr.
11/2/2012Response to Misc. Motion (specified in description)ADEQ's Resoibse To The Shinsky Appellants' Offer of Proof WiRespondent - Jennie E Barraza
11/6/2012Misc. Motion (specified in description)Shinsky Reply to ADEQ's Response re Offer of ProofAppellant - G. Van Velsor Wolf Jr.
11/30/2012Post-Hearing MemorandumRosemont's Closing BriefIntervenor - Norman D. James
11/30/2012Proposed Findings of Fact and Conclusions of LawRosemont's Proposed Findings of Fact and Conclusions of LawIntervenor - Norman D. James
11/30/2012Post-Hearing MemorandumRosemont's Response to Proposed Findings of FactsIntervenor - Norman D. James
11/30/2012Proposed Findings of Fact and Conclusions of LawADEQ's Proposed Findings of Fact and Conclusions of LawRespondent - Jennie E. Barraza
11/30/2012Post-Hearing MemorandumADEQ's Post-Hearing Legal MemorandumRespondent - Jennie E. Barraza
12/5/2012Misc. Motion (specified in description)Stipulated Motion to Extend Time for Filing Appellant - G. Van Velsor Wolf Jr.
12/5/2012Misc. Motion (specified in description)Prposed Order re Stipulated Motion to Extend Time to FileAppellant - G. Van Velsor Wolf Jr.
12/5/2012Post-Hearing OrderCASE MANAGEMENT ORDER No. 18Administrative Law Judge - Thomas Shedden
12/7/2012Misc. NoticeAdvisement of prior action updating combined exhibit listWebmaster - Webmaster
1/4/2013Post-Hearing MemorandumCBD Post-Hearing Reply MemoInterested Party - Lawrence V. Robertson, Jr.
1/4/2013Post-Hearing MemorandumShinsky Appellants Response to ADEQ & RosemontAppellant - G. Van Velsor Wolf Jr.
1/4/2013Post-Hearing MemorandumShinsky Appellants Reply in Support of Post-Hearing MemoAppellant - G. Van Velsor Wolf Jr.
1/18/2013Post-Hearing MemorandumRosemont's Supplemental Clarification of Legal AuthorityIntervenor - Norman D. James
4/26/2013Misc. NoticeAdvisement of Unavailability of Website 4/26/2013Webmaster - Webmaster
5/31/2013Order Closing RecordCASE MANAGEMENT ORDER No. 19Administrative Law Judge - Thomas Shedden
6/17/2013Administrative Law Judge DecisionALJ Decision transmitted 6-12-2013Webmaster - webmaster
7/16/2013, posted 9/4/2013Final Agency ActionFinal Agency ActionWebmaster - webmaster
8/23/2013Misc. NoticeRequest for Copy of the Administrative RecordIntervenor - Norman D. James
8/28/2013Misc. NoticeNotice of Filing Complaint for Judicial ReviewAppellant - G Van Velsor Wolf Jr
1/6/2014Certification of RecordCertification of Record on AppealWebmaster - webmaster
1/7/2014Misc. NoticeAdvisement of posting of electronic Certification of RecordWebmaster - webmaster

Click here to file a document in this matter.
(Parties only - Password required)